Mafia Mafia Mafia! (New Thread Exists)

[Kleene Onigiri]

Let's lynch Akonyl, he knows too much :x

Then you don't know how much I know 8)

Then you're really a spy? Let's lynch him! XD

Since it should be obvious by now that I trust nobody who reveals their role out loud, especially if it's a good role, I point my finger at Holmes.  How convenient that, unlike Agasa, you can't prove that you're Sherry.  It's more than likely that you're actually Vermouth disguised as Sherry and trying to prove your innocence by flaunting your role.  

He can't prove that he's Sherry right now. But that's also the case for Callid proofing that he is Takagi (besides maybe for Araide to know if he really healed XCommando).
And I don't think he (Holmes) needs to be Vermouth disguised as Sherry. It can be another option too.

People, lynch Callid. I´m Sherry and nobody can trick me or slander. I accompanied him the previous night and his smell is one of the leading B.O members.

Hmm, seems like I have to explain myself after such heavy incriminations. Luckily my role isn't that important, so the BO will not be able to kill of an important person easily.

I'm Takagi.
Because I thought anyone would expect Xcommando to get killed the first night (I didn't believe that would actually happen, as the BO isn't as stupid to kill someone who is so likely to be shielded), I investigated if anyone healed him. I found out that he was indeed healed, but I don't think that I can announce who did so, because if Araide got killed we would be in a worse position than when I got lynched (although this situation is not a favourable one either). Now at least one of you knows that I'm speaking the truth.

Of course I can't give you any (other) proofs that I'm indeed Takagi and not in the BO, since the game hasn't progressed very far and I do not have any other information. However, at least we know now (and if you don't believe me, you'll know after my death - let's hope that there aren't four BOs (after my death and an additional one in the night, there'd be as many BO as townsfolk and we'd lose)) that Holmes is in the BO.
Logically, I'll lynch him.

How come you thought XCommando would be attacked?

[Conia]

How come you thought XCommando would be attacked?

Is the most predictable thing in this game. Xcommando always dies.

[Sakina]

Sakina knows what she is doing!

Hey, I can think things through.  Is it not common knowledge that in order to make a successful bluff you have to raise the risk?  If you're playing BS/peanut-butter and jelly/whatever you call it, you can't just play down one card when bluffing.  You have to raise the risk and play down two or three in order to successfully bluff the other players.  They're more likely to think that you're not bluffing if you do that.  So claiming a role that is minor and you cannot prove is worthless while claiming a role that has much more power and yet you still cannot prove is a much better bet for bluffing.  And since if you actually had that role you would want to stay alive and would likely not reveal that role to the public, I think it's a safe bet to say that that person is bluffing.  

At least that's my reasoning...

[Conia]

It is a good reasoning, but both Holmes and you doesn't have proof, so as you are saying, you're playing a plural number of cards. Time will tell...

[Sakina]

It is a good reasoning, but both Holmes and you doesn't have proof, so as you are saying, you're playing a plural number of cards. Time will tell...

Yea, there's no proof, just speculation.  And this early in the game there won't be a lot of proof which makes it easier to bluff.  *shrug*

More like time will kill more townspeople and BO members. 

[Conia]

I think I just figured on which side of the game you are Sakina

[Sakina]

I think I just figured on which side of the game you are Sakina

Well that's easy to figure out, I'm always on the mafia side.  But I always want to win, too.  So I cheer for the deaths even when I'm a townsperson.  Doesn't mean I don't try to kill the BO, though. 

Gin ftw!  I had a wonderful time as Gin. 

[Kleene Onigiri]

I think I just figured on which side of the game you are Sakina

Well that's easy to figure out, I'm always on the mafia side.  But I always want to win, too.  So I cheer for the deaths even when I'm a townsperson.  Doesn't mean I don't try to kill the BO, though. 

Gin ftw!  I had a wonderful time as Gin. 

Once a BO always a BO, huh? (even if you're not officially a BO Member)

Sakina knows what she is doing!

Hey, I can think things through.  Is it not common knowledge that in order to make a successful bluff you have to raise the risk?  If you're playing BS/peanut-butter and jelly/whatever you call it, you can't just play down one card when bluffing.  You have to raise the risk and play down two or three in order to successfully bluff the other players.  They're more likely to think that you're not bluffing if you do that.  So claiming a role that is minor and you cannot prove is worthless while claiming a role that has much more power and yet you still cannot prove is a much better bet for bluffing.  And since if you actually had that role you would want to stay alive and would likely not reveal that role to the public, I think it's a safe bet to say that that person is bluffing. 

At least that's my reasoning...

But I think Holmes behavior is very suspicious too, since he revealed that he is Sherry right from the start :x

How come you thought XCommando would be attacked?

Is the most predictable thing in this game. Xcommando always dies.

I thought XCommando always suicides XD

[Sakina]

I think I just figured on which side of the game you are Sakina

Well that's easy to figure out, I'm always on the mafia side.  But I always want to win, too.  So I cheer for the deaths even when I'm a townsperson.  Doesn't mean I don't try to kill the BO, though. 

Gin ftw!  I had a wonderful time as Gin. 

Once a BO always a BO, huh? (even if you're not officially a BO Member)

Of course!  If I leave then they'll kill me.  o.o

Sakina knows what she is doing!

Hey, I can think things through.  Is it not common knowledge that in order to make a successful bluff you have to raise the risk?  If you're playing BS/peanut-butter and jelly/whatever you call it, you can't just play down one card when bluffing.  You have to raise the risk and play down two or three in order to successfully bluff the other players.  They're more likely to think that you're not bluffing if you do that.  So claiming a role that is minor and you cannot prove is worthless while claiming a role that has much more power and yet you still cannot prove is a much better bet for bluffing.  And since if you actually had that role you would want to stay alive and would likely not reveal that role to the public, I think it's a safe bet to say that that person is bluffing. 

At least that's my reasoning...

But I think Holmes behavior is very suspicious too, since he revealed that he is Sherry right from the start :x

How come you thought XCommando would be attacked?

Is the most predictable thing in this game. Xcommando always dies.

I thought XCommando always suicides XD

No, not always.  In the very first game, Ctu and I were BO members (I was Gin and Ctu was Vodka).  We killed xCommando first.  Then in the second game he messed up with his role as Vermouth and thus suicided.    I'm quite surprised he's not dead already.

[Kleene Onigiri]

I think I just figured on which side of the game you are Sakina

Well that's easy to figure out, I'm always on the mafia side.  But I always want to win, too.  So I cheer for the deaths even when I'm a townsperson.  Doesn't mean I don't try to kill the BO, though. 

Gin ftw!  I had a wonderful time as Gin. 

Once a BO always a BO, huh? (even if you're not officially a BO Member)

Of course!  If I leave then they'll kill me.  o.o

Sakina knows what she is doing!

Hey, I can think things through.  Is it not common knowledge that in order to make a successful bluff you have to raise the risk?  If you're playing BS/peanut-butter and jelly/whatever you call it, you can't just play down one card when bluffing.  You have to raise the risk and play down two or three in order to successfully bluff the other players.  They're more likely to think that you're not bluffing if you do that.  So claiming a role that is minor and you cannot prove is worthless while claiming a role that has much more power and yet you still cannot prove is a much better bet for bluffing.  And since if you actually had that role you would want to stay alive and would likely not reveal that role to the public, I think it's a safe bet to say that that person is bluffing. 

At least that's my reasoning...

But I think Holmes behavior is very suspicious too, since he revealed that he is Sherry right from the start :x

How come you thought XCommando would be attacked?

Is the most predictable thing in this game. Xcommando always dies.

I thought XCommando always suicides XD

No, not always.  In the very first game, Ctu and I were BO members (I was Gin and Ctu was Vodka).  We killed xCommando first.  Then in the second game he messed up with his role as Vermouth and thus suicided.    I'm quite surprised he's not dead already.

Let's ditch all reasoning and clues then and lynch XCommando to make it a tradition

[Conia]

I think I just figured on which side of the game you are Sakina

Well that's easy to figure out, I'm always on the mafia side.  But I always want to win, too.  So I cheer for the deaths even when I'm a townsperson.  Doesn't mean I don't try to kill the BO, though. 

Gin ftw!  I had a wonderful time as Gin. 

Once a BO always a BO, huh? (even if you're not officially a BO Member)

Of course!  If I leave then they'll kill me.  o.o

Sakina knows what she is doing!

Hey, I can think things through.  Is it not common knowledge that in order to make a successful bluff you have to raise the risk?  If you're playing BS/peanut-butter and jelly/whatever you call it, you can't just play down one card when bluffing.  You have to raise the risk and play down two or three in order to successfully bluff the other players.  They're more likely to think that you're not bluffing if you do that.  So claiming a role that is minor and you cannot prove is worthless while claiming a role that has much more power and yet you still cannot prove is a much better bet for bluffing.  And since if you actually had that role you would want to stay alive and would likely not reveal that role to the public, I think it's a safe bet to say that that person is bluffing. 

At least that's my reasoning...

But I think Holmes behavior is very suspicious too, since he revealed that he is Sherry right from the start :x

How come you thought XCommando would be attacked?

Is the most predictable thing in this game. Xcommando always dies.

I thought XCommando always suicides XD

No, not always.  In the very first game, Ctu and I were BO members (I was Gin and Ctu was Vodka).  We killed xCommando first.  Then in the second game he messed up with his role as Vermouth and thus suicided.    I'm quite surprised he's not dead already.

Let's ditch all reasoning and clues then and lynch XCommando to make it a tradition

I vote for that.

[Callid]

Let's ditch all reasoning and clues then and lynch XCommando to make it a tradition

Well, as funny as it would be...
We do know the identity of a BO member - shouldn't we lynch him first?
After all, Xcommando can't run away - or wait, if he is a foreigner, he can. But if he is, he's out of the Japan at the moment anyway. 

[Conia]

What a twist xD!

As for me, I'll be back on Sunday, if this Round ends and next starts on Sunday,COUNT ME IN(Probably I'll log in, but just in case )

Oh, and my final guess is BO will win this Round. You know, Third time lucky

[Sakina]

What a twist xD!

As for me, I'll be back on Sunday, if this Round ends and next starts on Sunday,COUNT ME IN(Probably I'll log in, but just in case )

Oh, and my final guess is BO will win this Round. You know, Third time lucky

The BO is only allowed to win if I'm in it. 

[Kleene Onigiri]

Let's ditch all reasoning and clues then and lynch XCommando to make it a tradition

Well, as funny as it would be...
We do know the identity of a BO member - shouldn't we lynch him first?
After all, Xcommando can't run away - or wait, if he is a foreigner, he can. But if he is, he's out of the Japan at the moment anyway. 

"We" do not know it for sure. Since at least one of you is lying, and there is no solid proof to know which one.