Mafia Mafia Mafia! (New Thread Exists)

[Kleene Onigiri]

People, lynch Callid. I´m Sherry and nobody can trick me or slander. I accompanied him the previous night and his smell is one of the leading B.O members.

Sherry(Ai), shrunken scientist

    * Has a strong sense of the BO. She may accompany anyone at night and day (therefore she's able to accompany two people from morning to morning). The accompanied will learn that Ai accompanied him. If the accompanied is either Akai, Kir or from the BO, Ai will get the impression that he's from the BO, and will learn through the strength of the scent if the target is one of the leading members (Gin, Vermouth, Anakota, Bourbon). Ai cannot be fouled by a disguise or by a slander.

Uhm, I think you can be tricked (from Eisuke) so that you get "no results". But you can't be tricked in the way of someone slandering the target or with a disguise.

People, lynch Callid. I´m Sherry and nobody can trick me or slander.

Unless you're lying.

Unless you want to protect Callid ;p


Although I don't have any idea myself as to who is who ^^"

[bluekaitou1412]

People, lynch Callid. I´m Sherry and nobody can trick me or slander.

Unless you're lying.

Lie and you get lynched by me!

[Sakina]

Lynching time!  The best part of a townsperson's day.  Angry mobs!  Yay!  I'm thinking to lynch the person who wants to be lynched...

[Callid]

People, lynch Callid. I´m Sherry and nobody can trick me or slander. I accompanied him the previous night and his smell is one of the leading B.O members.

Hmm, seems like I have to explain myself after such heavy incriminations. Luckily my role isn't that important, so the BO will not be able to kill of an important person easily.

I'm Takagi.
Because I thought anyone would expect Xcommando to get killed the first night (I didn't believe that would actually happen, as the BO isn't as stupid to kill someone who is so likely to be shielded), I investigated if anyone healed him. I found out that he was indeed healed, but I don't think that I can announce who did so, because if Araide got killed we would be in a worse position than when I got lynched (although this situation is not a favourable one either). Now at least one of you knows that I'm speaking the truth.

Of course I can't give you any (other) proofs that I'm indeed Takagi and not in the BO, since the game hasn't progressed very far and I do not have any other information. However, at least we know now (and if you don't believe me, you'll know after my death - let's hope that there aren't four BOs (after my death and an additional one in the night, there'd be as many BO as townsfolk and we'd lose)) that Holmes is in the BO.
Logically, I'll lynch him.

[Holmes]

Just trust me on this one. It says that Ai cannot be fouled by disguise or slander.

If I´m wrong then I will ask the game mod of what the hell happened and you can lynch me.

[Akonyl]

People, lynch Callid. I´m Sherry and nobody can trick me or slander. I accompanied him the previous night and his smell is one of the leading B.O members.

Sherry(Ai), shrunken scientist

    * Has a strong sense of the BO. She may accompany anyone at night and day (therefore she's able to accompany two people from morning to morning). The accompanied will learn that Ai accompanied him. If the accompanied is either Akai, Kir or from the BO, Ai will get the impression that he's from the BO, and will learn through the strength of the scent if the target is one of the leading members (Gin, Vermouth, Anakota, Bourbon). Ai cannot be fouled by a disguise or by a slander.

Uhm, I think you can be tricked (from Eisuke) so that you get "no results". But you can't be tricked in the way of someone slandering the target or with a disguise.

Just trust me on this one. It says that Ai cannot be fouled by disguise or slander.

If I´m wrong then I will ask the game mod of what the hell happened and you can lynch me.

Right, Sherry can indeed be tricked, but that would just get no result (she'll learn that she failed to accompany anyone because she got lost or something). However, if Sherry gets either an "extremely positive", "positive" or "negative" result, it's 100% correct, except in the cases of Akai or Kir, where she gets a "positive" anyway.

Also, even though you all are pointing out your lynches (Callid to Holmes, Sakina to Beastly, etc) make sure you PM them to me in the end. There's 11 hours and 30 minutes left to go!

[Conia]

LOL, ranger didn't make it to Night 2...again...

I don't wanna look for the answer, so I'll ask here: Callid said XC was healed. Neverthless,ranger DIED. What is that I'm missing?

[Akonyl]

though I shouldn't really be talking about game matters that aren't obvious rule questions:

LOL, ranger didn't make it to Night 2...again...

I don't wanna look for the answer, so I'll ask here: Callid said XC was healed. Neverthless,ranger DIED. What is that I'm missing?

I don't think you're particularly missing anything. Callid wasn't saying that xcommando being healed had anything to do with ranger's death, rather he was using it as proof of him being Takagi (as if "XXX healed Xcommando" was investigated as being true, and he pointed it out, the doctor would have some reason to believe him (because he'd know it's right also), hence Callid saying "at least one of you knows that I'm speaking the truth")

[Conia]

though I shouldn't really be talking about game matters that aren't obvious rule questions:

LOL, ranger didn't make it to Night 2...again...

I don't wanna look for the answer, so I'll ask here: Callid said XC was healed. Neverthless,ranger DIED. What is that I'm missing?

I don't think you're particularly missing anything. Callid wasn't saying that xcommando being healed had anything to do with ranger's death, rather he was using it as proof of him being Takagi (as if "XXX healed Xcommando" was investigated as being true, and he pointed it out, the doctor would have some reason to believe him (because he'd know it's right also), hence Callid saying "at least one of you knows that I'm speaking the truth")

Does that mean XC and another person were attacked by the BO, but the Doc saved XC?

[Akonyl]

though I shouldn't really be talking about game matters that aren't obvious rule questions:

LOL, ranger didn't make it to Night 2...again...

I don't wanna look for the answer, so I'll ask here: Callid said XC was healed. Neverthless,ranger DIED. What is that I'm missing?

I don't think you're particularly missing anything. Callid wasn't saying that xcommando being healed had anything to do with ranger's death, rather he was using it as proof of him being Takagi (as if "XXX healed Xcommando" was investigated as being true, and he pointed it out, the doctor would have some reason to believe him (because he'd know it's right also), hence Callid saying "at least one of you knows that I'm speaking the truth")

Does that mean XC and another person were attacked by the BO, but the Doc saved XC?

the action of healing occurs whether or not the person needed it (so you can investigate it truthfully anyway). The only difference between a not-needed healing and a saving heal is in a saving heal, the doctor + victim + protectors all learn that there was an attack and that the victim was healed through it. Nothing is learned in a not-needed heal (except the doctor knwos he healed someoen who didn't need it).

The only way two people can die in a night (that I can think of right now) is if the lovers are killed, however a doctor can't heal a lover through suiciding over their lover's death, so it's impossible for only one to die.

[Conia]

Doubt cleared. Thanks Akonyl.

[Kleene Onigiri]

Let's lynch Akonyl, he knows too much :x

[Conia]

Let's lynch Akonyl, he knows too much :x

Then you don't know how much I know 8)

[Sakina]

Since it should be obvious by now that I trust nobody who reveals their role out loud, especially if it's a good role, I point my finger at Holmes.  How convenient that, unlike Agasa, you can't prove that you're Sherry.  It's more than likely that you're actually Vermouth disguised as Sherry and trying to prove your innocence by flaunting your role.  

[Conia]

Sakina knows what she is doing!