Mafia - Round 9 (Town wins!)

[Abs.]

Don't worry Akonyl the town won't lynch you.  You have already proven yourself to be irrefutably town, and you have at least one other person that can back that up.

I guess what's left is whether you believe me or conia  :-\

It's either me or the guy behind the bars.

I still have to hear word from James Rye. Until then, I don't have a lynching target.

I've said it before to you conia, and I'll say it again here: That's a really weak reason.

Yeah, I'm not 100% sure about Rye I'll admit (but I'm pretty darn sure about Tommy).  But I know for sure about conia.  Lynch either of them and I guess you'll know for sure, but it's getting really desperate here folks.  I think I screwed up by getting arrested, but it's not all over yet folks!

I don't know if anyone was as dedicated (or as desperate to contribute something  ;D ) as I was, but I scoured this thread from the beginning and conia just doesn't make sense unless he is B.O.  For example:

Throughout the game, trusting people has become the hardest thing in the game. The best thing is to use your abilities, if any, to check the other guys.

...And yet he trusted James Rye with absolutely no basis, as he openly admits later.

Now a number of people whose roles were known to conia are dead.

I guess I don't want to say, "Lynch conia!" but I know that if I weren't in jail right now I would do so.

[Akonyl]

I have deduced information of great importance. It helps to consolidate the role of James Rye as not-Black.

however, with pofa dead, we all have to vote on this one. No abstaining from anyone aside from Xpon. After all, we can't be sure that Abs is Vodka and not Eisuke.

[Detective Tommy]

Nice! A Mafia was arrested, but why don´t we know the role I remember the role would be revealed if arrested, I guess I´m wrong.
So, "Who is James Black?" debate will start in any moment.

We don't know if the arrested was BO.
Page 1 says anyone can be arrested as long as "Arrest ____ for doing _____" is correct.

The arrested said he was Eisuke, and said he believes I'm James Black.

[Schillok]

We don't know if the arrested was BO.
Page 1 says anyone can be arrested as long as "Arrest ____ for doing _____" is correct.

The arrested said he was Eisuke, and said he believes I'm James Black.

Only if the action is a "crime".
And crimes are: killing, slandering, abducting, disguising, removing bodies, intimidating/tricking, frightening and stealing. I might have missed one though...

[Holmes]

mmm ... I think I´ll trust you Det.Tom, but I don´t knoe if to lynch conia or James Rye, but I think I´ll lynch conia.

[Conia]

We don't know if the arrested was BO.
Page 1 says anyone can be arrested as long as "Arrest ____ for doing _____" is correct.

The arrested said he was Eisuke, and said he believes I'm James Black.

Only if the action is a "crime".
And crimes are: killing, slandering, abducting, disguising, removing bodies, intimidating/tricking, frightening and stealing. I might have missed one though...

Eisuke's tricking also counts as a crime. So Abs.'s  claim can be true.

mmm ... I think I´ll trust you Det.Tom, but I don´t knoe if to lynch conia or James Rye, but I think I´ll lynch conia.

Weren't you convinced by the arrest? Come on!

[Detective Tommy]

We don't know if the arrested was BO.
Page 1 says anyone can be arrested as long as "Arrest ____ for doing _____" is correct.

The arrested said he was Eisuke, and said he believes I'm James Black.

Only if the action is a "crime".
And crimes are: killing, slandering, abducting, disguising, removing bodies, intimidating/tricking, frightening and stealing. I might have missed one though...

Eisuke's tricking also counts as a crime. So Abs.'s  claim can be true.

mmm ... I think I´ll trust you Det.Tom, but I don´t knoe if to lynch conia or James Rye, but I think I´ll lynch conia.

Weren't you convinced by the arrest? Come on!

No Holmes, lynch James Rye. Another person and I are lynching him.
He's been lying about his role for about.. 6 phases. Lynch him to avoid a tie.

[CTU]

We don't know if the arrested was BO.
Page 1 says anyone can be arrested as long as "Arrest ____ for doing _____" is correct.

The arrested said he was Eisuke, and said he believes I'm James Black.

Only if the action is a "crime".
And crimes are: killing, slandering, abducting, disguising, removing bodies, intimidating/tricking, frightening and stealing. I might have missed one though...

Eisuke's tricking also counts as a crime. So Abs.'s  claim can be true.

mmm ... I think I´ll trust you Det.Tom, but I don´t knoe if to lynch conia or James Rye, but I think I´ll lynch conia.

Weren't you convinced by the arrest? Come on!

you must admit you have a weak reason for defending Rye so we can lynch you today or lynch you tomorrow if/when Rye is revealed to be ORG

or you two are the lovers and you both die in which case we will take out an ORG member ether way

[Abs.]

or you two are the lovers and you both die in which case we will take out an ORG member ether way

Remember B.O. members can both be lovers as well, like in the last round.  Since no B.O. has died yet, it's very likely that's the case this round as well.

Lynch one, lynch both.

[CTU]

or you two are the lovers and you both die in which case we will take out an ORG member ether way

Remember B.O. members can both be lovers as well, like in the last round.  Since no B.O. has died yet, it's very likely that's the case this round as well.

Lynch one, lynch both.

True...so if they are ORG/lovers we take out 2 this day

[Conia]

We don't know if the arrested was BO.
Page 1 says anyone can be arrested as long as "Arrest ____ for doing _____" is correct.

The arrested said he was Eisuke, and said he believes I'm James Black.

Only if the action is a "crime".
And crimes are: killing, slandering, abducting, disguising, removing bodies, intimidating/tricking, frightening and stealing. I might have missed one though...

Eisuke's tricking also counts as a crime. So Abs.'s  claim can be true.

mmm ... I think I´ll trust you Det.Tom, but I don´t knoe if to lynch conia or James Rye, but I think I´ll lynch conia.

Weren't you convinced by the arrest? Come on!

you must admit you have a weak reason for defending Rye so we can lynch you today or lynch you tomorrow if/when Rye is revealed to be ORG

or you two are the lovers and you both die in which case we will take out an ORG member ether way

I've said already that my investigation for James Rye came out false tonight. Since it is the first time I'm investigating him, getting a False result does change things. I'll have to wait for now.

And it really looks people aren't trusting me, even with the arrest thing. Look, I made the first arrest attempt back in Day 1. It's impossible for a BO member to do that. So, wouldn't the real police officer here say he made the arrest attempt, which would turn me instatly in a BO member? I'll answer for you: NO, because it was me!

[Akonyl]

or you two are the lovers and you both die in which case we will take out an ORG member ether way

Remember B.O. members can both be lovers as well, like in the last round.  Since no B.O. has died yet, it's very likely that's the case this round as well.

Lynch one, lynch both.

True...so if they are ORG/lovers we take out 2 this day

lynch James Rye then, if you think they're lovers. We'll deal with Conia tomorrow, or he'll off himself when Rye dies, if he's really a lover. What we know right now is that James Rye is not James Black, I really doubt he's Kid disguised as James Black.

[Abs.]

Look, I made the first arrest attempt back in Day 1. It's impossible for a BO member to do that. So, wouldn't the real police officer here say he made the arrest attempt, which would turn me instatly in a BO member? I'll answer for you: NO, because it was me!

Nice try, but I will always point out the one truth!

Prep. actions
There are decisions that a player has to make during the Preparation Phase.
Roles with Prep. Actions: Vermouth, KID, Yumi, Sonoko, Hakuba, Makoto

* Disguise
- Roles with that action: Vermouth, KID
- The player chooses a number of players to disguise as. (GM tells how many players to choose) The player will then disguise as that role and be able to use their actions, just like being that role.

Disguises are taken during the Preparation Phase.  So as early as Night 1, you could have attempted an arrest, Vermouth.

[CTU]

We don't know if the arrested was BO.
Page 1 says anyone can be arrested as long as "Arrest ____ for doing _____" is correct.

The arrested said he was Eisuke, and said he believes I'm James Black.

Only if the action is a "crime".
And crimes are: killing, slandering, abducting, disguising, removing bodies, intimidating/tricking, frightening and stealing. I might have missed one though...

Eisuke's tricking also counts as a crime. So Abs.'s  claim can be true.

mmm ... I think I´ll trust you Det.Tom, but I don´t knoe if to lynch conia or James Rye, but I think I´ll lynch conia.

Weren't you convinced by the arrest? Come on!

you must admit you have a weak reason for defending Rye so we can lynch you today or lynch you tomorrow if/when Rye is revealed to be ORG

or you two are the lovers and you both die in which case we will take out an ORG member ether way

I've said already that my investigation for James Rye came out false tonight. Since it is the first time I'm investigating him, getting a False result does change things. I'll have to wait for now.

And it really looks people aren't trusting me, even with the arrest thing. Look, I made the first arrest attempt back in Day 1. It's impossible for a BO member to do that. So, wouldn't the real police officer here say he made the arrest attempt, which would turn me instatly in a BO member? I'll answer for you: NO, because it was me!

Still why would you rick yourself for Rye without having good reason (aka your ORG, Lovers, or both) I really want to know you reason for being so trusting

[Conia]

Look, I made the first arrest attempt back in Day 1. It's impossible for a BO member to do that. So, wouldn't the real police officer here say he made the arrest attempt, which would turn me instatly in a BO member? I'll answer for you: NO, because it was me!

Nice try, but I will always point out the one truth!

Prep. actions
There are decisions that a player has to make during the Preparation Phase.
Roles with Prep. Actions: Vermouth, KID, Yumi, Sonoko, Hakuba, Makoto

* Disguise
- Roles with that action: Vermouth, KID
- The player chooses a number of players to disguise as. (GM tells how many players to choose) The player will then disguise as that role and be able to use their actions, just like being that role.

Disguises are taken during the Preparation Phase.  So as early as Night 1, you could have attempted an arrest, Vermouth.

Oh, you're right.
Are you gonna search wild for everything I type here? I'm sure you are BO by now after your PMs...

We don't know if the arrested was BO.
Page 1 says anyone can be arrested as long as "Arrest ____ for doing _____" is correct.

The arrested said he was Eisuke, and said he believes I'm James Black.

Only if the action is a "crime".
And crimes are: killing, slandering, abducting, disguising, removing bodies, intimidating/tricking, frightening and stealing. I might have missed one though...

Eisuke's tricking also counts as a crime. So Abs.'s  claim can be true.

mmm ... I think I´ll trust you Det.Tom, but I don´t knoe if to lynch conia or James Rye, but I think I´ll lynch conia.

Weren't you convinced by the arrest? Come on!

you must admit you have a weak reason for defending Rye so we can lynch you today or lynch you tomorrow if/when Rye is revealed to be ORG

or you two are the lovers and you both die in which case we will take out an ORG member ether way

I've said already that my investigation for James Rye came out false tonight. Since it is the first time I'm investigating him, getting a False result does change things. I'll have to wait for now.

And it really looks people aren't trusting me, even with the arrest thing. Look, I made the first arrest attempt back in Day 1. It's impossible for a BO member to do that. So, wouldn't the real police officer here say he made the arrest attempt, which would turn me instatly in a BO member? I'll answer for you: NO, because it was me!

Still why would you rick yourself for Rye without having good reason (aka your ORG, Lovers, or both) I really want to know you reason for being so trusting

I've already explained how I reached that conclusion. I can explain it too you by PM if you want. If James is ORG, great because there'll be another BO taken down. And I know he isn't my lover, because I don't have one.