Mafia Round 18: Jungle Bells (Town wins)

[Eve]

It was directed at Kleene, you RMed me.

Oh.... *runs back*

[Akonyl]

Also, I found a graphic that might help players for this round:

Spoiler:

It might help. 

I like how after you inevitably reach the "lynch the bastard" part, if you claim that it worked, you get screwed, but if your attempt to lynch them doesn't work, you can eventually reach "gloat in their face".

Though I just realized that this is a BO flowchart, so yeah. :V

[Kleene Onigiri]

Thanks, I like to try to help and be called annoying because of that

@sherry:
She can poison someone every night, without any punishment or loosing APTX (if I got it right). Too powerful! D:
What if the BO found out someone can heal. Sherry will guess on araide, it will be wrong and no penalty. The next day, that player dies as Kobayashi for sure :V

I think there needs to be a penalty, otherwise the BO can APTX without end D: (and APTX is kinda loose anyway, tho that's because of players too XD I include myself here )
Anyway, I think it should be used up when APTXed wrong. Like the day version.
But for that, every time she kills the BO can get a extra APTX? It usually doesn't come to that that someone can kill a second time. even if, 2 extra APTX shouldn't hurt that much at the end. This was an idea from Akonyl (for sherries father even XD)


And yeah, you didn't answer every question yet :V Or you answered but didn't clarify it in the rules yet )

[Akonyl]

I think there needs to be a penalty, otherwise the BO can APTX without end D: (and APTX is kinda loose anyway, tho that's because of players too XD I include myself here )
Anyway, I think it should be used up when APTXed wrong. Like the day version.
But for that, every time she kills the BO can get a extra APTX? It usually doesn't come to that that someone can kill a second time. even if, 2 extra APTX shouldn't hurt that much at the end. This was an idea from Akonyl (for sherries father even XD)

if the "gain an aptx on killing " role was added though, it should be separate from the one who can aptx at night, imo.

As for sherry's night-aptx ability, I think it should undergo the normal APTX rules. Having the extra phase to APTX people is strong enough as-is, imo, because there are times when you learn someone's identity during the night and you have to wait a bit to kill them, when the immediate kill would have been that much more beneficial (especially with bourbon).

[Eve]

@ Kleene, Maybe Dus wants you to ask in German LOL

[Kleene Onigiri]

^^"

[Dus]

@Sherry: The same rules as for other APTXings apply now, but she has one backup APTX. So the second time she guesses wrong, she loses the ability. Which are the other rules that still need clarification?

[Akonyl]

rather than talking about backup aptxes and whatnot, I think it might just be clearer to say that "Sherry has 2 APTX that can be used for the Poison ability, which follow the same rues as other APTX", but that's just me.

[Kleene Onigiri]

@Sherry: The same rules as for other APTXings apply now, but she has one backup APTX. So the second time she guesses wrong, she loses the ability. Which are the other rules that still need clarification?

Sonoko and being able to arrest or not I guess. And it doesn't say what happens when the friend dies (aka, sonoko can't use the abilities anymore)


Cross-examine:
Does a crime that was done on the same phase count or not XD (didn't see the answer)


Idea to pinch-face:
Will the pinched one get a notice that he got pinched? XD Since you should notice that usually XD (disguised one will notice ofc, but not disguised players)
And if nakamori pinches the wrong one, can there be a drawback? Or a post that someone got slapped? (since nakamori pinches someone wrongly XD)

[Akonyl]

Idea to pinch-face:
Will the pinched one get a notice that he got pinched? XD Since you should notice that usually XD (disguised one will notice ofc, but not disguised players)
And if nakamori pinches the wrong one, can there be a drawback? Or a post that someone got slapped? (since nakamori pinches someone wrongly XD)

I would think someone not disguised would be more likely to notice that their face was pinched, actually

Dunno about the drawbacks, though.

[Dus]

No drawbacks, but you will be notified if your face was pinched.

I should have added everything now. (Including lovey-dovey)

[Eve]

@Sherry: The same rules as for other APTXings apply now, but she has one backup APTX. So the second time she guesses wrong, she loses the ability. Which are the other rules that still need clarification?

Sonoko and being able to arrest or not I guess. And it doesn't say what happens when the friend dies (aka, sonoko can't use the abilities anymore)


Cross-examine:
Does a crime that was done on the same phase count or not XD (didn't see the answer)


Idea to pinch-face:
Will the pinched one get a notice that he got pinched? XD Since you should notice that usually XD (disguised one will notice ofc, but not disguised players)
And if nakamori pinches the wrong one, can there be a drawback? Or a post that someone got slapped? (since nakamori pinches someone wrongly XD)

I think He has said something about
@ Eri: "knowing all crimes committed thus far" in other words, ALL crimes they have committed up to that point..... would result in a yes for Eri I think

@ Nakamori: A penalty would be good, too, how about if he pinches someone without a face mask, He can't pinches again for two phases? much like a pol being suspense?

[Akonyl]

the Detention ability isn't in red :V

[Abs.]

I'll join, because I have a feeling the mysterious role is "Abs." and it would be weird if I wasn't playing.  :D

Also, is "Hawaii" the new "Eisuke Convention" 

[Yurikochan]

I'll join, because I have a feeling the mysterious role is "Abs." and it would be weird if I wasn't playing.  :D

Also, is "Hawaii" the new "Eisuke Convention" 

The Eisuke Convention was in Hawaii

Also *glomps Pisco-sama*