Mafia--Round 8 (BO WINS)

[Paix672]

Seems like I misunderstood something. I PM'd Pofa and she cleared it up right now, so Xpon could really be Sonoko.^^;

[xpon]

Seems like I misunderstood something. I PM'd Pofa and she cleared it up right now, so Xpon could really be Sonoko.^^;

and you think i'll believe you with this? ? ?

please.. please.. explaine in more detailed.. and not in PM. here.. in this tread!

i demand you

[Paix672]

I can't really explain without giving out my role. I hope she can confirm it though. But if that's not possible I'll PM you and I'll explain everything.

[xpon]

I can't really explain without giving out my role. I hope she can confirm it though. But if that's not possible I'll PM you and I'll explain everything.

nope....GM wont tell us any info.. against the rule


that way .. it will look like i'm the one who randomly accuse and became a liar.... ...

[Kleene Onigiri]

I can't really explain without giving out my role. I hope she can confirm it though. But if that's not possible I'll PM you and I'll explain everything.

nope....GM wont tell us any info.. against the rule


that way .. it will look like i'm the one who randomly accuse and became a liar.... ...

Wrong. If a player was confused because of the rules/roles and ask the GM to confirm that he asked about rules/roles, then the GM can tell that in the thread when that player want it to be so.
But it depends on pofa how she sees this case.

Since making someone suspicious because he/she confused the rules is bad imo D: 1. we have new players (and paix is still kinda new ) and there are a lot of rule changes or rule changing discussions going on

[xpon]

arggggggggggg...


Paix672 PM me.

and now . after he reveal almost every think... i think i think ....


he is townie for now!. he have investigator. so i can make him prove him in the next day.


her role it too bad for blind linch.

so guys... vote for someone else okay!

Dont lynched Paix672  in day 1.... maybe in day 2

[nomemory]

and nomemory. / kain.. the sisters keep silence ... so ??

they are also in germany.

No, we're not. Just the same timezone. And I haven't been totally quiet either so stop accusing me based on me being being quiet.

[xpon]

and nomemory. / kain.. the sisters keep silence ... so ??

they are also in germany.

No, we're not. Just the same timezone. And I haven't been totally quiet either so stop accusing me based on me being being quiet.

we really need investigator for night 2. will you help me?

[nomemory]

and nomemory. / kain.. the sisters keep silence ... so ??

they are also in germany.

No, we're not. Just the same timezone. And I haven't been totally quiet either so stop accusing me based on me being being quiet.

we really need investigator for night 2. will you help me?

And what has that to do with anything I said?

[xpon]

i got info that nomomory is an investigator type... and Paix672 claimed he is investigator too.

[nomemory]

To you whom I have sent a pm and now everyone else, I made a mistake saying I have an investigationish role. I confused one thing with an other and didn't really think of that most people doesn't interpret it the same way I do. It was a newbie mistake but I suppose it might not look that way. Stay safe!

Just wanted to point this out again, I can't investigate. I'm doing this so people will not say I have been lying and start to distrust me because of it

[Schillok]

I got info as well that nomemory had investigator.
But when I tried to contact her yesterday - after I exposed quite a lot of hints pointing towards my identity - it turned out that everything was a misunderstanding and that she is not able to investigate. Or that is what she claimed. So we shouldn't trust her! And if I die by APTX today then it is very very likely that nomemory is with the BO.

The next suspect is xpon. I know, last game he behaved similarly and it turned out he was on the side of the town. But this time he is even more reckless and even more "greedy" to learn everything about the roles from other players. If he is really Sonoko or her BFF, then there should be someone backing up his claims, shouldn't there? Since noone ever did that - and since xpon doesn't even confirm that he is Sonoko - it seems to me like he is out here all along trying to find out our roles. Even the Detective Boys would not be able to identify if he was lying since their day-ability could only show that he is not Sonoko - and then he could claim he is the BFF and we would be back to square 1.

Lastly there are conia and holmes who might be BO according to commi-ninja. Again, if we vote for one of them then chances are slightly higher (46% for Holmes and Conia; 34% for other players) that they are really BO. If there were no other suspects I would vote for one of them but the way things are now... Still, it would be a good idea to check these two, the dream is a good lead for interrogations during the second night.
That is, if we can trust commi-ninja. He could be a BO himself, releasing a dream that suspects two townies hoping to kill either.

Right now my top suspect is nomemory. Claiming to be an investigator and PMing me asking for an alliance and the calling everything off once I started to reveal myself sounds very much like BO.

[xpon]

i told my best friend to stay low and take cover

because his role is better than me

[Schillok]

i told my best friend to stay low and take cover

because his role is better than me

I don't see how this statement should make me distrust you any less than I do already. If it weren't for the last game you would be my top suspect.


Concerning commi-ninjas dream. I just thought about it again... if we assume that commi-ninja has 34% of being BO that means we only trust his dream with a 66% probability. This means 66%*46% = 31%. So the chances of conie or Holmes being BO is about the same (or even a bit smaller) as for any other player. So I won't be voting for either of them.
Still, they are a good starting point for night 2.

[nomemory]

I never meant to say I had investigation abilities, what I wanted to say was that I had that kind of role, an "investigation"-role. Like I said I mixed some things up.