Mafia Mafia Mafia! Pt. 2! (Game 4: Town wins!)

[CTU]

Satou  was avenged but we still have org members on the lose 

[Holmes]

Dam I was caught ...

[pofa]

Dam I was caught ...

Don't be that way. It was an awesome arrest scene. They'll make movies about you. 

As for today's lynching...looks like most people want it to be Beastly. *rifles around for evidence* Setting aside Abs.'s random suggestion (if it was indeed random), there is always the "This or That" post that Akonyl referenced back at the start. And TheBlind's theory about why he voted for Xcommando could be true.

*looks around* Where is Xcommando? He hasn't talked in a while.

[Beastly]

Dam I was caught ...

Don't be that way. It was an awesome arrest scene. They'll make movies about you. 

As for today's lynching...looks like most people want it to be Beastly. *rifles around for evidence* Setting aside Abs.'s random suggestion (if it was indeed random), there is always the "This or That" post that Akonyl referenced back at the start. And TheBlind's theory about why he voted for Xcommando could be true.

*looks around* Where is Xcommando? He hasn't talked in a while.

Let me talk first, I pmed both Abs and Ctu. PM me if you need something

[Conia]

Dam I was caught ...

Don't be that way. It was an awesome arrest scene. They'll make movies about you. 

As for today's lynching...looks like most people want it to be Beastly. *rifles around for evidence* Setting aside Abs.'s random suggestion (if it was indeed random), there is always the "This or That" post that Akonyl referenced back at the start. And TheBlind's theory about why he voted for Xcommando could be true.

*looks around* Where is Xcommando? He hasn't talked in a while.

Xcommando is gone for a couple of days, he told us some days ago.

[TheBlind]

Let me talk first, I pmed both Abs and Ctu. PM me if you need something

Wait, the townspeople are allowed to talk via PM?

I though we couldn't do that, only the Mafia could.

[Conia]

Yes you can, but be careful, because Mafia members know each, don't PM the wrong guy!

[TheBlind]

I really dont get you. Both of your deduction are contradicting.

First, you said if Holmes voted for Xcommando, isnt that will create a cover too like what you said about Commi-Ninja voting for me.

Then if Commi-Ninja voted for me is it just same for Xcommando if your deduction is true?

But then again, if you want my role kindly PM me. I thought this will not happen again. Since when i PM someone i died. But when i didnt PM someone i didnt die. So yea PM me TheBlindie

I thought you would say that. There is no contradiction. The two of you voted for Xcommando to blend in with the rest of the village, not for a cover. You assumed the poll to favor Xcommando and decided to use that to your advantage but also knew it would be foolish for all of you to vote for him. Like Sakina and Akonyl said, it's risky for all of the mafia to vote for the same target, which is why Ninja voted for you. He wasn't trying only create a cover by voting for you, he was trying to vote differently without affecting the desired results "Xcommando lynched, he's innocent?...Lets kill TheBlind". So what better way than to vote for one of his own, knowing no one suspected you at the time.

He would help in the plan and in case things took a bad turn for the worse and eyes turned to you, just like know, he would have an alibi...but my eyes are too sharp for such tricks.

Wait!  Hold on there...  If Commi-Ninja is B.O. by virtue of voting for Beastly's lynching, wouldn't Ctu be suspect as well?  I assume the reason you clear Ctu of the same reasoning is because you have some privileged information regarding Ctu?

Nevertheless, your reasoning points in the way of my random suggestion, so I approve!

Tsk Tsk Abs, didn't you hear when I said only five players are unknown to me. Ctu isn't one of them...but you are.

[TheBlind]

Yes you can, but be careful, because Mafia members know each, don't PM the wrong guy!

What? No one's PMed me!!
I feel so left out and unwanted!

[Kleene Onigiri]

I really dont get you. Both of your deduction are contradicting.

First, you said if Holmes voted for Xcommando, isnt that will create a cover too like what you said about Commi-Ninja voting for me.

Then if Commi-Ninja voted for me is it just same for Xcommando if your deduction is true?

But then again, if you want my role kindly PM me. I thought this will not happen again. Since when i PM someone i died. But when i didnt PM someone i didnt die. So yea PM me TheBlindie

I thought you would say that. There is no contradiction. The two of you voted for Xcommando to blend in with the rest of the village, not for a cover. You assumed the poll to favor Xcommando and decided to use that to your advantage but also knew it would be foolish for all of you to vote for him. Like Sakina and Akonyl said, it's risky for all of the mafia to vote for the same target, which is why Ninja voted for you. He wasn't trying only create a cover by voting for you, he was trying to vote differently without affecting the desired results "Xcommando lynched, he's innocent?...Lets kill TheBlind". So what better way than to vote for one of his own, knowing no one suspected you at the time.

He would help in the plan and in case things took a bad turn for the worse and eyes turned to you, just like know, he would have an alibi...but my eyes are too sharp for such tricks.

Wait!  Hold on there...  If Commi-Ninja is B.O. by virtue of voting for Beastly's lynching, wouldn't Ctu be suspect as well?  I assume the reason you clear Ctu of the same reasoning is because you have some privileged information regarding Ctu?

Nevertheless, your reasoning points in the way of my random suggestion, so I approve!

Tsk Tsk Abs, didn't you hear when I said only five players are unknown to me. Ctu isn't one of them...but you are.

Wasn't that me? And Sakina can't tell you any strategy/info/deduction, since she's gm :p

[Commi-Ninja]

I thought you would say that. There is no contradiction. The two of you voted for Xcommando to blend in with the rest of the village, not for a cover. You assumed the poll to favor Xcommando and decided to use that to your advantage but also knew it would be foolish for all of you to vote for him. Like Sakina and Akonyl said, it's risky for all of the mafia to vote for the same target, which is why Ninja voted for you. She wasn't trying only create a cover by voting for you, she was trying to vote differently without affecting the desired results "Xcommando lynched, he's innocent?...Lets kill TheBlind". So what better way than to vote for one of his own, knowing no one suspected you at the time.

She would help in the plan and in case things took a bad turn for the worse and eyes turned to you, just like know, she would have an alibi...but my eyes are too sharp for such tricks.

If you paid more attention, this would be more convincing. 

[TheBlind]

Wasn't that me? And Sakina can't tell you any strategy/info/deduction, since she's gm :p

Also, no it doesn't make them too powerful.  Remember, the BO are supposed to blend in with the normal people so having them not vote would be a dead giveaway.  And since they're trying to blend in, voting for whoever they want isn't always a good idea.  

It was Sakina clarifying why Mafia also is allowed to vote without making them too powerful.
I also have my eye on you Kleene as I believe there are four members and you are one of the five I can't label.

If you paid more attention, this would be more convincing.  

If you paid more attention, you would know that my record for guessing someone's gender correctly is 1-56. That's my only deduction weakness...guessing people's gender. But lets forget about that, I have a question for you Commi.

If you could be one animal in the zoo, which one would you be?

[Commi-Ninja]

If you could be one animal in the zoo, which one would you be?

What difference does that make?  I'll answer it for you, anyway.  If I could be one animal in the zoo, I'd be.... an otter.

[Holmes]

If you could be one animal in the zoo, which one would you be?

What difference does that make?  I'll answer it for you, anyway.  If I could be one animal in the zoo, I'd be.... an otter.

LOL 

[TheBlind]

If you could be one animal in the zoo, which one would you be?

What difference does that make?  I'll answer it for you, anyway.  If I could be one animal in the zoo, I'd be.... an otter.

Thank you for giving me the missing piece. You see, I received a puzzle of sorts that was incomplete. Without the last piece, I could not see the message it was trying to deliver but now I have it and with it your guilt*smirk*.

There is only one of you left I'm afraid:
Kleene Onigiri
Abs
Bluekaitou1412
*It hard to hide among only two innocent people, isn't it 4th member*

80% chance of being B.O.
Beastly
Commi-Ninja