Mafia Round 19: Shake Up Christmas

The home to DCTP Forum Mafia as well as any other type of random forum game that you can conjure up.

Should Mafia 19 count as a real Game?

Yes
15
79%
No
4
21%
 
Total votes: 19
User avatar
Schillok
GCA UAC U AUG AUA

Posts:
699

Re: Mafia Round 19: Shake Up Christmas (Day 8 - Game Ends) B

Post by Schillok »

Kleene Onigiri wrote: Carter was arrested.
That's like the revenge criminal got his target killed by someone else. :V

So, I also don't think Carter won :V Sorry D:
On the other hand it is quite hard to stay alive that long. And getting rid of 4+1 police without getting killed and arrested is kinda unfair.

Tho the criminal needs some changes. I don't mind that the bomber can be threatened. Since the town could do that too once they know the identity.
But what happens after the Bomber killed all police? I think once a criminal wins, he'll travel out of town or something like that. And won't be "in the game" anymore. Since he/she won anyway.
Because once they won, they can choose whatever side to support D: But they are kinda like a neutral faction :x
Yeah, I have wondered about that too. Of course a criminal remaining in the game would have a huge impact on whatever side he decides for. I was considering to keep this as a "reward" for the criminal, to be allowed to do whatever he/she desires for completing his query before the game was over. But I know that this would be a nightmare to balance and will likely decide the outcome of the rest of them game in some cases. (Like the criminal working with the BO while the town has no idea who he is.)
But it would feel kinda lame to be removed from playing the game if I were Okuda and killed my target during night 2 or 3 more or less at random.
Maybe allow the criminal to choose a side then? Or have him lose his killing ability and leave him in the game otherwise?

I think the last one feels best: Allow the criminal to stay in the game. Have him lose the killing ability. He/she can help whatever side he/she wants, wreak havoc if desired - but without the killing ability his influence on the game will be much lower.


What do we learn from this round? Never ever kill Kleene ;D Kidding ^^
But if I would have survived that attack, I would have known for sure that ako and breva are town :x Because I told them my role. So, why would they attack me during night while they can easily APTX me? :x
Especially since I had other reasons to trust them already.
Yeah, things would probably had looked bad then. Did you tell them about Carter already? I mean, obviously if Akonyl arrested him/her just a night later we would have been in the same situation (number of townies) again. And your dead confirmed that you were town for sure - I am not sure if Akonyl knew you were town 100% then so he might have held back with the arrest to not expose himself.
Really hard to predict how it had developed otherwise. But it is pretty realistic that the town might have won.
Image
Akonyl
Community Hero

Posts:
4200

Re: Mafia Round 19: Shake Up Christmas (Day 8 - Game Ends) B

Post by Akonyl »

I was fairly sure the was Yusaku (partially due to DT  :-X), and woulda believed her more when she said "Meme is BO" and we lynched her and Meme was Pisco. But, alas.
User avatar
Kleene Onigiri
Community Rice Warrior
*punches Akonyl*

Posts:
2479

Re: Mafia Round 19: Shake Up Christmas (Day 8 - Game Ends) B

Post by Kleene Onigiri »

I also survived that long for being slandered :P

Also I dunno what the rules were. If you still win or not when you were arrested before you killed all police. If it was decided before that you'll still win, then it's a win of course.


Loosing the killing ability sounds best :V


And both breva and akonyl knew about the lists. And I also could have used reveal culprit :P Since I knew that carter was able to use observe from eve.
Image
Keyhole drawn by Yuri Iwamoto <3
Spoiler: Secret Santa gift from Commi-Ninja <3
A Black Organization Christmas Carol (need to fix the link)
3DS Friend Code: 4141 3202 3514

༼ つ ◕_◕ ༽つ Giff holidays
Abs.
DCTP Staff Hero

Posts:
3270

Re: Mafia Round 19: Shake Up Christmas (Day 8 - Game Ends) B

Post by Abs. »

What's with the always slandering Kleene?  T_T
Your opinion is always requested in Abs.' Random Polls of Whenever
User avatar
PT
Community Mad Scientist
to cammel's bav we go!

Posts:
1800

Re: Mafia Round 19: Shake Up Christmas (Day 8 - Game Ends) B

Post by PT »

It's a survival tactic. :P

iirc, she was a suspect at that point, so it made sense to slander her then. :P
pofa wrote: I have never done a single thing wrong in mafia, never one lie or act of violence
Eve
Hiatus :P

Posts:
4651

Re: Mafia Round 19: Shake Up Christmas (Day 8 - Game Ends) BO won...

Post by Eve »

Pop in just to say: Honestly the rule that surprised me the most that BO can poison me as:
Eve as Shiratori
Eve as Satou
In the same Night :| My fault for not reading the rules carefully XD

Eve needs to read the rules before playing, seriously XD too many new rules :P
Image Image
[quote="朱砂泪"]
镜湖翠微低云垂佳人å¸
User avatar
PT
Community Mad Scientist
to cammel's bav we go!

Posts:
1800

Re: Mafia Round 19: Shake Up Christmas (Day 8 - Game Ends) BO won...

Post by PT »

Even if that rule hadn't been there, you still would've died that day because we were pretty sure you were Satou. :P We almost only poisoned you as Satou anyway.
pofa wrote: I have never done a single thing wrong in mafia, never one lie or act of violence
Eve
Hiatus :P

Posts:
4651

Re: Mafia Round 19: Shake Up Christmas (Day 8 - Game Ends) BO won...

Post by Eve »

PhoenixTears wrote: Even if that rule hadn't been there, you still would've died that day because we were pretty sure you were Satou. :P We almost only poisoned you as Satou anyway.
Yeah, figures XD

Though through this game, I've learned something, too: Balancing roles is one thing, balancing players is another ... :-\
Like Some players were great disadvantage to certain team XD

And for once, I've experienced what JR felt like when he was town for real for the first time: Nobody trusts you ::) lol
Image Image
[quote="朱砂泪"]
镜湖翠微低云垂佳人å¸
User avatar
PT
Community Mad Scientist
to cammel's bav we go!

Posts:
1800

Re: Mafia Round 19: Shake Up Christmas (Day 8 - Game Ends) BO won...

Post by PT »

Aww, Eve, I trusted you. :P Especially once you got suspended and I didn't have to worry about you investigating me. ;)

Also, you managed to confuse pofa by saying you were attacked by a sniper. :P There wasn't even a sniper in the round, but at one point she mentioned something about our sniper and I had to remind her that we didn't have one. :P
pofa wrote: I have never done a single thing wrong in mafia, never one lie or act of violence
User avatar
Kleene Onigiri
Community Rice Warrior
*punches Akonyl*

Posts:
2479

Re: Mafia Round 19: Shake Up Christmas (Day 8 - Game Ends) BO won...

Post by Kleene Onigiri »

Abs. wrote: What's with the always slandering Kleene?  T_T
any rules I change are backfiring on me :V
I also almost got lynched in minimafia XD But I decided lo APTX someone else instead so that one vote wasn't erased :x *phew*
PhoenixTears wrote: It's a survival tactic. :P

iirc, she was a suspect at that point, so it made sense to slander her then. :P
No no :P I'm always a suspect :P
It's ok tho XD It's a good tactic :P It's just hard to counter as the one being slandered :x
Image
Keyhole drawn by Yuri Iwamoto <3
Spoiler: Secret Santa gift from Commi-Ninja <3
A Black Organization Christmas Carol (need to fix the link)
3DS Friend Code: 4141 3202 3514

༼ つ ◕_◕ ༽つ Giff holidays
User avatar
PT
Community Mad Scientist
to cammel's bav we go!

Posts:
1800

Re: Mafia Round 19: Shake Up Christmas (Day 8 - Game Ends) BO won...

Post by PT »

That's true, you pretty much are always a suspect. :P

I have a feeling after this round I will be too. :-X XD If, you know, BO doesn't kill me before Night 3.
pofa wrote: I have never done a single thing wrong in mafia, never one lie or act of violence
Eve
Hiatus :P

Posts:
4651

Re: Mafia Round 19: Shake Up Christmas (Day 8 - Game Ends) BO won...

Post by Eve »

PhoenixTears wrote: Aww, Eve, I trusted you. :P Especially once you got suspended and I didn't have to worry about you investigating me. ;)

Also, you managed to confuse pofa by saying you were attacked by a sniper. :P There wasn't even a sniper in the round, but at one point she mentioned something about our sniper and I had to remind her that we didn't have one. :P
LOL, I was surprised, after the Akonyl bit, I stopped accusing ppl, and kept on attacking you with the Logical mind she said" -crap ::) and ppl still trust you XD
In the back of their mind, even now, PT is still town XD forever and ever XD
I've read somewhere that if you're known to be town for a long time, you'll have a great advantage later on, boy, that was so right XD

XD lol, yay!!! XD

And PT, I don't think ppl will really suspect you :P
And I've lied about not using my calculator, I did... except it wasn't concrete enough to I had to shoot randomly... not to mention I didn't incorporate the rules since Dus's game :|
Image Image
[quote="朱砂泪"]
镜湖翠微低云垂佳人å¸
User avatar
Kleene Onigiri
Community Rice Warrior
*punches Akonyl*

Posts:
2479

Re: Mafia Round 19: Shake Up Christmas (Day 8 - Game Ends) BO won...

Post by Kleene Onigiri »

Eve wrote:
PhoenixTears wrote: Aww, Eve, I trusted you. :P Especially once you got suspended and I didn't have to worry about you investigating me. ;)

Also, you managed to confuse pofa by saying you were attacked by a sniper. :P There wasn't even a sniper in the round, but at one point she mentioned something about our sniper and I had to remind her that we didn't have one. :P
LOL, I was surprised, after the Akonyl bit, I stopped accusing ppl, and kept on attacking you with the Logical mind she said" -crap ::) and ppl still trust you XD
In the back of their mind, even now, PT is still town XD forever and ever XD
I've read somewhere that if you're known to be town for a long time, you'll have a great advantage later on, boy, that was so right XD

XD lol, yay!!! XD

And PT, I don't think ppl will really suspect you :P
And I've lied about not using my calculator, I did... except it wasn't concrete enough to I had to shoot randomly... not to mention I didn't incorporate the rules since Dus's game :|
Actually, PT was also on my 1. deduction list :V And I thought: Schillok or PT totally did it! XD
Later I interrogated Commi first, since she said something in the thread what made me thought she could be BO :V
Image
Keyhole drawn by Yuri Iwamoto <3
Spoiler: Secret Santa gift from Commi-Ninja <3
A Black Organization Christmas Carol (need to fix the link)
3DS Friend Code: 4141 3202 3514

༼ つ ◕_◕ ༽つ Giff holidays
Eve
Hiatus :P

Posts:
4651

Re: Mafia Round 19: Shake Up Christmas (Day 8 - Game Ends) BO won...

Post by Eve »

Kleene Onigiri wrote: Actually, PT was also on my 1. deduction list :V And I thought: Schillok or PT totally did it! XD
Later I interrogated Commi first, since she said something in the thread what made me thought she could be BO :V
\^_^/ yay for Kleene XD

Still this was a fun game XD, I've lived past Day 1 \(^_^)/ a cause for celebration XD
Also, there were no DBs? I don't wanna download the spreadsheet :P
Image Image
[quote="朱砂泪"]
镜湖翠微低云垂佳人å¸
User avatar
PT
Community Mad Scientist
to cammel's bav we go!

Posts:
1800

Re: Mafia Round 19: Shake Up Christmas (Day 8 - Game Ends) BO won...

Post by PT »

Nope, no DBs. :P

@Kleene: well, I didn't do it. :P (Ako arrested me for the only crime I committed the entire game. :-X)
pofa wrote: I have never done a single thing wrong in mafia, never one lie or act of violence
Post Reply