Mafia - Round 9 (Town wins!)

[Kleene Onigiri]

If is right, maybe they would have voted someone else or Beastly as well. You can't blame nonvoters for this. It's also possible to say that if more people had abstained their vote then Beastly wouldn't have been lynched

Yeah, you´re right. I´m sorry for being angry. It´s just... Megure at night 1 and we (= those 7 people) killed Shinichi which does leave us at point zero. Almost.
Like Sebolains said, those 7 should watch out. -.-
Too bad the arrest failed also...

@Kleene

You forgot to write down my vote on xpon in the list. *xpon:1* is missing. It´s not important, just want to let you know.

Oh, in the summary. Yeah, edited it thx. Well, it was just 1 vote anyway and wasn't a big impact xD

Kleene, can you verify some things?

- Do dreams get sent out every night? If so, do you create them?
- Does BO help make the tape? Like... does the GM make the tape or BO does?

There is 1 dream every night. And the people/roles in it are choosen randomly. But I write a "dream" according to that. With hints or without hints. Depends how mean I am :p

The BO can make a tape. It's their choice. If I feel like it I could add aspects to it, which could be real hints or fake hints. I could also add hints in the "not tape" things. Also, either real or fake hints.

So you basically won't know it it's a real hint or not. If it's a tape by me or by BO or a mix ;p
Yes, I'm mean >D

Ps. Gonna sleep now.

[Kleene Onigiri]

Kleene, can you verify some things?

- Do dreams get sent out every night? If so, do you create them?
- Does BO help make the tape? Like... does the GM make the tape or BO does?

Dreams go out every night without exception and the GM creates them.
The tape is purely made by the BO. The GM can't change anything.

look at my post :x There was a Hint section added to the rules anyway D:

[Akonyl]

To everyone saying "oh no shinichi died", yeah he's a bad character to lose, but oh well. It's Beastly, after all.

Anyway, as far as votes: the breakdown goes:
Beastly: Akonyl, Commi-Ninja, Laurell, Abs, Ctu, KainTheVampire, Beastly
Xpon: James Rye
Abs: DetTommy, pofa, conia, Sebolians
Holmes: Beastly

and of the people that voted for beastly in the thread, not many voiced their opinion loudly. Thus, if the BO split their vote, they wouldn't have much of a way to know which person is getting lynched, which would be bad for them. As, if Abs was town as well, they run the risk of not lynching any townies with a tie, and if Abs is a BO, they'd risk lynching their own. So, not to say that Abs is definitively BO, just that the majority of the BO probably voted Beastly.

And because at the very least I and one other person in there aren't BO, they can attempt to blend in. So, you can't deduce who the BO is really, but you can deduce that Detective Tommy, pofa, conia and Sebolians are less likely to be BO. It's not 100%, but I'd trust their words more than the words of others.

Anyway, let's see how the night goes, I guess.

[Beastly]

Follow the hint of death

[Beastly]

I forgot to replied to _____ god damn it could have been a vital clue

[Detective Tommy]

I'm really pissed off cause WE DIDN'T GET A DREAM!!!

[Holmes]

I guess I should apologise you, Beastly.

[Beastly]

Oh well Shinichi dies with alot of clues

[pofa]

I say some people should investigate/interrogate/whatever conia tonight. If we can trust him we can probably trust James Rye as well. The suitcase is in play tonight, so it will be difficult, but...

[James Rye]

Was it Conia that said to vote for Beastly?
And Conia said James Rye was cleared...

Ah, nope. He just defended me (thank god, it was succesful) and said to lnych Abs..

Listen to me people: I'm a detective, which means I can investigate, and I used my investigations to prove James Rye and he is indeed a townie (Of course, I won't reveal my results).
And not only that, James Rye started to move us, the town, which his reasoning. He's a newbie here, and we all know what happens to the guy that tries to get something on Day 1: The BO blames him/her of being suspicious and finally gets lynched. So, let's stop this: Abs. reacted to James Rye reasoning and tried to put suspicion on him. As I've said earlier, James Rye is innocent. Remember last Round: xpon had Det.Tommy who proved his innocence, yet nobody believed him and got lynched. We can't let that happen again!

So, we have to lynch Abs.!

then

Let's say, for example, I investigate if James Rye interrogated someone who he previously told me the name.  My result comes true, which means he can interrogate, and the only BO that can interrogate is Vermouth disguises as a detective. What are the probabilities of that happening?

@Conia, you investigated James Rye night 1? And got a non-BO?
I just want to make sure I didn't misread. I'm thinking about following you.

Indeed.

He just used an example, not how it really went like.^^

then after pofas questions/doubts

Well, I didn't mean "investigator," as I'm sure there are several of those. I meant, specifically, "detective." As in, Shinichi/Heiji/Kogoro/Hakuba. These are the only ones who can interrogate, and there probably wouldn't be three out of the four in one game.

I understand that you don't want to reveal the results of your investigation, but you started this.  ;) Since you're using the argument that "James Rye can interrogate, therefore he's probably not BO" to keep us from lynching him, it's probably important whether you actually investigated that or not.

Again, interrogation was just an example, but I get your point
And I can't reveal my investigations since it would be bad for James Rye if he plan to keep his identity a secret. If he agrees to reveal his ability, then I'll post my results.

I think i have to talk with Conia about that matter. If it helps us to get some more allys (none of the beastly voters, in my eyes all of them are very suspicious. Sorry guys/girls. ), well maybe i will let him do that. Maybe not. It depends on how much it does reveals. Also prob is that Beastly got killed after revealing his investigations. Don´t want that the same happens to Conia.^^

So yeah... all i can say is that i have a new target then xpon (i let the turtle live for another day ). Hope i will survive night 2 to vote for this person.

[Schillok]

Well, welcome Beastly (Shinichi) among the dead. Grab a tee (if you can... being non-corporal has its disadvantages...) and enjoy the show.


We really need something for dead people to do as well. Beside haunting this thread of course... 

[Akonyl]

I'm surprised nobody ever mentioned the possibility of conia being Gin yesterday, just the possibility of him being an investigator-disguised vermouth. Thankfully, I can now say that conia is in fact, not Gin. Cough cough.

So anyway, unless he's a disguised vermouth, I'd say he should be trusted for now.

[Detective Tommy]

Conia knows my role.
Even though it's kinda useless...

But if I die from APTX... You know who to trust..



Also, I kind of hinted my role to Pofa, so he might know it too...

[Sebolains]

I'm surprised nobody ever mentioned the possibility of conia being Gin yesterday, just the possibility of him being an investigator-disguised vermouth. Thankfully, I can now say that conia is in fact, not Gin. Cough cough.

So anyway, unless he's a disguised vermouth, I'd say he should be trusted for now.

So akonyl... what's up with your lynching a townie after declaring you were lyncing Abs?
suspicioussssss

[James Rye]

To everyone saying "oh no shinichi died", yeah he's a bad character to lose, but oh well. It's Beastly, after all.

Anyway, as far as votes: the breakdown goes:
Beastly: Akonyl, Commi-Ninja, Laurell, Abs, Ctu, KainTheVampire, Beastly
Xpon: James Rye
Abs: DetTommy, pofa, conia, Sebolians
Holmes: Beastly

and of the people that voted for beastly in the thread, not many voiced their opinion loudly. Thus, if the BO split their vote, they wouldn't have much of a way to know which person is getting lynched, which would be bad for them. As, if Abs was town as well, they run the risk of not lynching any townies with a tie, and if Abs is a BO, they'd risk lynching their own. So, not to say that Abs is definitively BO, just that the majority of the BO probably voted Beastly.

Going (under the) to bed now. Good night everyone.^^

And because at the very least I and one other person in there aren't BO, they can attempt to blend in. So, you can't deduce who the BO is really, but you can deduce that Detective Tommy, pofa, conia and Sebolians are less likely to be BO. It's not 100%, but I'd trust their words more than the words of others.

Anyway, let's see how the night goes, I guess.

Uhm... how could Beastly vote for himself and Holmes at the same time?

But what if those who didn´t voiced their opinion out loud are BO? Like they already knew 3/4 people (the loud ones) will probably vote for Beastly and they kinda knew who Beastly was, so they send some of then (i think 3/4) to make sure it will have the most votes and considering that xpon, Elika didn´t posted much (-> probably won´t vote) and nomemory forfeit (-> no vote, of cource your vote wouldn´t have changed everything, nomemory), so considering it all it was a sure win-win on their situation.
Dunno if ALL of them voted for Beastly (if so we´re lucky), but i´m also sure that lots´of them are in this group. You know, that includes you as well, Akonyl?

Follow the hint of death

I will. Thanks for posting them! At least you died while giving your all.

1.Abs slanders Beastly (false)
2.Abs kills Akonyl (false)
3.Akonyl search if Okiya is in the game (false)
4.Abs investigate if Okiya is in the game (false)
5.Abs kills Beastly (false)

His first and last investigations, now we know for sure that they are real.^^

Looks like i know what the B.O. are planning if you're not a BO, don't vote me Atleast for this time

Looks like we can narrow down the BO-list to the 7 people who voted for Beastlys death. At the very least 2 of them should be in, 3 is more plausible and 4 would be gold mine.

I'm getting suspected of:

Abs
Holmes
And

Slightly Laurell.

Okay, his list of possible Bo members.

Anyways, i suggest Sherry to follow Holmes and Okiya to check if KID is in the game. And if i survive this day someone protect me

Ill vote for Holmes so we can get a 1 VS 1 for sure. Don't know to my lovers/BF if ever i have one.

Guess that means there´s a Sherry in the game. I wonder if Sherry did follow at day 1 (that is if we have her in the players) and what result she got. He/she with the role didn´t posted anything about Beastlys suggestion (i hope Sherry/Haibara is not Elika or xpon; mean of me i know, but weel, that´s how i am^^;).

Though more people doubted Abs. then Beastly´s Holmes.

Laurell PM sent. I'll post that later depending on your answer

Reply now. Just a note: Somehow suspicious.

So Laurell´s pm was somehow suspicious.

You might be Sonoko, right? I know some people here who have the roles of whom you've mentioned. So, Sonoko is the one left, I guess, for you.

From Laurell so he know More than 10 roles in a night???? WOW

So... Laurell knows 10 roles in one night? Is that even possible to begin with? Also his reasoning that Beastly is Sonoko was wrong like we saw at Shinichi`s death. Dunno if that makes him a BO or not, but like Beastly says suspicious.

I forgot to replied to _____ god damn it could have been a vital clue

His death words. I think in the ____ should be *Laurell* and Beastly believes that could have been a vital clue...
So we have his list, his vote for Holmes and his suspicion on Laurell cause he, well i admitt i also think so since i readed the *tell me first, then i protect you* kinda-post, has suspicious written all over it.

What do you guys think? Of cource i for myself, won´t believe the reasoning/accusations of the Beastly voters as much as the rest. Call me biased if you want.