"Mafia Round 21," or, "Boom With A View!" (BO and Bomber win

[Yurikochan]

PS. I love you Pofa. But you know that. <3

@Hayley: You need to work on your evilness, I didn't trust you at all. <3

[miikosan]

I guess people told me too much stuff about themselves, that's why XD

Although I didn't expect blurf to trust me right away, but he told me his action, therefore I figured out his role.

The bulk of all the infos I gathered were thanks to mystery though. : D

[Schillok]

Well, for some reason pofa had not put my vote into his excel file.

You were APTXed, so your vote didn't count.

I know. But Ayumis vote was written in there, and she was also APTXed.

[ProfParanoia]

Well, for some reason pofa had not put my vote into his excel file.

You were APTXed, so your vote didn't count.

I know. But Ayumis vote was written in there, and she was also APTXed.

Could that be why ? *points to bold*

[Kleene Onigiri]

@Kleene: Actually it was Tommy's weirdness that made me gravitate more to trusting you. I wouldn't
have told you the police officer's name no matter what cause I'm tight lipped. And when I got Miaka's result from Tommy I knew you had to be Anokata, cause he did that round 15. With claiming Genta when he was Mitsuhiko. He could have lied yes. But it was you or him. And you creeped meout just a little bit and I fed you and Hayley lots of fake information. I still love you. but I was disappointed in the town. more than anything with the lack of votes when I pmmed people! XD!

Also PS: you may want to talk to Akonyl about stealing girl's panties. <3

Shihokudo: Why do you always pick on me.

I see :V

Tho you're not really tight lipped :x Since you kinda told me that miaka can observe and Hopeless could be Kir. If hopeless would be town, she could have been APTXed or I would know her ability at least :x

[xpon]

i will trust you kleene....

i will......

[Kleene Onigiri]

i will trust you kleene....

i will......

Sure you can trust me when I'm not playing XD

[xpon]

you didnt play?

[Akonyl]

breva contacting us via caseclosed: Yeah, this was a very "meh" thing because cheating (including pretending to cheat, coughcough) is pretty lame and I question why people still do it :V.

I request some clarification regarding the above.

though we may have contacted her fairly soon anyway because Dus was outed as BO, breva found the BO via seeing that CaseClosed was viewing the BO Strategy topic so she was able to contact us a little quicker than expected. There was also someone else who used the pretense of cheating to lure a BO out, and then admitted afterward that they hadn't cheated at all.

Though, I fail to see the difference, really. The fact that there's a BO board made for convenience's sake should have no effect on the game (hence why it was even moved out of OT so that you couldn't see when it had new posts), yet some people seem to think it should be taken into account as part of plans anyway. :I

[pofa]

@Schillok: I was having trouble with the computer when I saw your vote, so since it wouldn't count anyway I didn't bother adding it onto the spreadsheet. It wouldn't have mattered, since the APTX'd people were the only ones who sent in votes.

@Spy/deduction: Spy and deduction both had 7 people the first time. The spy rules say 5 people for 14-16 townies, and there were 20-21 townies at the time, so I bumped the numbers up for both since it says the GM gets to decide the number. By the time he used spy again, there were only 5 townies left. If Mystery had used deduction when more people had died, there would have been fewer names on her list too.

@Akonyl/Abs.: Actually, I'm not sure whether breva actually saw CC viewing the BO board or whether she just noticed CC was online and visible and took a shot at saying "hey, you're BO right lol." :l But either way I'm not sure what we can do about it, since any penalty would just confirm the target player is BO.

[PT]

Someone... Hayley, maybe and I were discussing making it a rule that you hide your status in games - especially for the BO, but for the town as well because if the BO is forced to do so, then if you see someone's online, that automatically makes them town and it's a possible ally. Which still feels kinda like cheating.

Although looking at the other mafia thread, looks like that's already been discussed anyway.

@Dus: I did forgive you. But I can't miss an opportunity to tease you about betraying me.

[Yurikochan]

@Kleene: Actually it was Tommy's weirdness that made me gravitate more to trusting you. I wouldn't
have told you the police officer's name no matter what cause I'm tight lipped. And when I got Miaka's result from Tommy I knew you had to be Anokata, cause he did that round 15. With claiming Genta when he was Mitsuhiko. He could have lied yes. But it was you or him. And you creeped meout just a little bit and I fed you and Hayley lots of fake information. I still love you. but I was disappointed in the town. more than anything with the lack of votes when I pmmed people! XD!

Also PS: you may want to talk to Akonyl about stealing girl's panties. <3

Shihokudo: Why do you always pick on me.

I see :V

Tho you're not really tight lipped :x Since you kinda told me that miaka can observe and Hopeless could be Kir. If hopeless would be town, she could have been APTXed or I would know her ability at least :x

I thought Miaka was BO/Chianti.

And with Hayley, Gin, or Anokata.

Akonyl was figured out to be Vodka or Bourbon. (how you kept claiming to be tricked)

[Akonyl]

@Akonyl/Abs.: Actually, I'm not sure whether breva actually saw CC viewing the BO board or whether she just noticed CC was online and visible and took a shot at saying "hey, you're BO right lol." :l But either way I'm not sure what we can do about it, since any penalty would just confirm the target player is BO.

imo, just make it a rule that you have to set your status to hidden and that if anyone's seen with a non-hidden status they'll be killed by the GM immediately.

[CTU]

@Akonyl/Abs.: Actually, I'm not sure whether breva actually saw CC viewing the BO board or whether she just noticed CC was online and visible and took a shot at saying "hey, you're BO right lol." :l But either way I'm not sure what we can do about it, since any penalty would just confirm the target player is BO.

imo, just make it a rule that you have to set your status to hidden and that if anyone's seen with a non-hidden status they'll be killed by the GM immediately.

if they show there status, then they will get themselves killed anyways

[Akonyl]

@Akonyl/Abs.: Actually, I'm not sure whether breva actually saw CC viewing the BO board or whether she just noticed CC was online and visible and took a shot at saying "hey, you're BO right lol." :l But either way I'm not sure what we can do about it, since any penalty would just confirm the target player is BO.

imo, just make it a rule that you have to set your status to hidden and that if anyone's seen with a non-hidden status they'll be killed by the GM immediately.

if they show there status, then they will get themselves killed anyways

the point though is that if you don't actually punish it, then all the town can just not hide their status because they have nothing to hide, leaving the ones who hide their status as the BO.