Mafia - Round 11 (Game Over: BO Wins)

[nomemory]

GM: Grawwbear Rohoph

Players:
1. xpon
2. Yurikochan
3. Ctu
4. Detective Tommy
5. PhoenixTears
6. nomemory
7.

[PT]

I just wish Abs would tell us.
We wouldn't do anything.. I'm just curious

I'm curious too. But if that person realized they were in the wrong and have asked Abs. or anyone else not to tell everyone, then I'll respect their privacy. (Not saying that this is the case, but it is a possibility.)

Also, Abs., did you delete your post or am I losing my mind? (Cause that's possible. I need to get to sleep.)

[Yurikochan]

I just wish Abs would tell us.
We wouldn't do anything.. I'm just curious

I'm curious too. But if that person realized they were in the wrong and have asked Abs. or anyone else not to tell everyone, then I'll respect their privacy. (Not saying that this is the case, but it is a possibility.)

Also, Abs., did you delete your post or am I losing my mind? (Cause that's possible. I need to get to sleep.)

I saw Ab's post too and now its gone.

[Akonyl]

For some reason you were unable to accomplish your task.

How am I suppose to know that I wasn't tricked and my action failed?
Cause I assumed you were trying to make the game interesting and added storyline.

I couldn't just tell you "Hey you can't interrogate Commi because she's not in Japan yet."  And it is stated in the rules that no actions may be taken on players who are not in Japan/in transit (except discombobulate, which can confuse the traveler so that he or she misses the flight)

Anyhow, don't worry.  The BO thought there was an Eisuke in the game as well.

how do you long-range discombobulate someone? Give them a really confusing phone call?

4.  Thou shalt not talk at all about the game (no matter how small a difference you think it'll make) after death.

boo-urns

Also: Am I the only one that was actually kind of amused that we got so thoroughly deceived by Kleene? Like I said before, good job, Kleene!

having been on the BO side with her before, I know she can be tricksy. Unfortunately my thoughts mattered little this round

Investagate 1  xpon investigate pofa  FALSE
Investagate 2  akonyl investigate abs  FALSE
Investagate 3  laurell protect kain  FALSE
Investagate 4  theblind trick commi-ninja  FALSE
Investagate 5  xpon protect akonyl  FALSE

I doubt Rhenandrial is xpon, Akonyl, Laurell or TheBlind because why would he investigate himself?
Just more random info in narrowing it down.

maybe that's just what I wanted you to think.

Also, wasn't Rhenandriel the one that posted their role in the thread right off the bat or something? (I don't know, the post was deleted before I saw it.)

he posted something about akai and then deleted it, so yeah I'm pretty sure he was akai that round and let it slip.

As for signups:

GM: Grawwbear Rohoph

Players:
1. xpon
2. Yurikochan
3. Ctu
4. Detective Tommy
5. PhoenixTears
6. nomemory
7. Akonyl
8.

[xpon]

Oh, I forgot.
One voodoo doll for xpon,

why? did i do wrong?

It wasn't any of the police officers because you murdered all of them in the End Game post. Possibly Kazuha or Araide? I know xpon mentioned something about "Kazuha's charm" at some point but I don't know if he actually knew Kain's role and was basing it off that or because he's xpon and comes up with wild theories without any encouragement.

you made me feel that i was the BIGGEST liar

I wanted to trust Kleene, but nothing she did with me made any sense, and made me suspect her MORE and MORE. Unfortunately, MANY OTHER PEOPLE already had to spill my role to EVERYONE ELSE, so it didn't matter how I played. By the time pofa sent out the PM to (in a sense) everyone, I knew the game ended for townies. Told Tommy and xpon to go with my idea, which would have taken care of Kleene. (Sorry to make you sound evil, Kleene)

But the way you told me, is like you and tommy want to reduce 1 or 2 vote against ctu

GAME POST PART ONE:

COMMANDMENTS OF MAFIA

1.  Thou shalt not form alliances before knowing roles.
2.  Thou shalt not insult and swear at other players no matter how passions flare.
3.  Thou shalt not be a xponheinous pervert.
4.  Thou shalt not talk at all about the game (no matter how small a difference you think it'll make) after death.

What else?

Stay tuned for Kain's role in Part Two!

point 1,3 and 4 is okay.
but i demand you take my name out of that line. that is not funny.
i'm NOT just a pervert but i'm a PERVERTED LOLICON !!!!!!!

Only one person English is that bad but he already said it wasn't him and I kinda trust that it wasn't...

i can let you go after insulting me in other aspect. but not this ones! XPONESE is a language that only the selected ones can understand and use it in real life!

and I know What Kain Role is.

Its FBI

---

GM: Grawwbear Rohoph

Players:
01. xpon
02. Yurikochan
03. Ctu
04. Detective Tommy
05. PhoenixTears
06. nomemory
07. Akonyl
08.
09.
10.
11.

[Beastly]

So i guess James Rye is correct

[blurfbreg]

(I'm guessing you hit "Reply to All" instead of "Quote"?)

Spoiler: Don't read me, pofa; it'll be like Pandora's box

It wouldn't seem like pofa clicked reply to all because she never PMed to me before. It probably has to do with the first line of that PM, which has my name, Tommy's and Laurell's. But I don't think she wants us to talk about it.

It wasn't any of the police officers because you murdered all of them in the End Game post. Possibly Kazuha or Araide? I know xpon mentioned something about "Kazuha's charm" at some point but I don't know if he actually knew Kain's role and was basing it off that or because he's xpon and comes up with wild theories without any encouragement.

you made me feel that i was the BIGGEST liar

I would agree that xpon is the biggest liar. During his PMs with me this round, he claimed Ran would protect him, Kazuha has already given him the charm to protect him from other people, gives a percentage of how much he thinks Tommy is Anokata (Without much evidence except for the fact that info is leaking and he doesn't have BO scent), he claims he is Sherry and tells me Kain might have discombobulated Tommy and doing so randomly (when FBIs can't do that). It's a lot more lying than Kleene did. She only had one lie (she lied about being Okiya) .

I wanted to trust Kleene, but nothing she did with me made any sense, and made me suspect her MORE and MORE. Unfortunately, MANY OTHER PEOPLE already had to spill my role to EVERYONE ELSE, so it didn't matter how I played. By the time pofa sent out the PM to (in a sense) everyone, I knew the game ended for townies. Told Tommy and xpon to go with my idea, which would have taken care of Kleene. (Sorry to make you sound evil, Kleene)

But the way you told me, is like you and tommy want to reduce 1 or 2 vote against ctu

I thought I said I wanted to die, so I can kill Kleene with vengeance. That's why I said to make everyone who knew about me to vote for me (which only Tommy could do since he's the one collaborating the info).

Can't play next round. I'll be getting real busy. I might join the game in 3.5 week's time (mid-August). It's been fun playing with my allies (you know who you are) and Kleene as I try to unravel her mystery. Ancient riceball, I hope to be your ally next time.

[Beastly]

Actually, xpon did that so that he can waste a B.O's APTX, we actually lost one APTX because of Xpon claiming to be Ai.

[Beastly]

Just a clue:

You can investigate if a person only use a black suitcase for example

Beastly faked investigated Kleene in killing Akonyl.

But i hope this will be taken out next game.

[nomemory]

Just a clue:

You can investigate if a person only use a black suitcase for example

Beastly faked investigated Kleene in killing Akonyl.

But i hope this will be taken out next game.

Why should it be taken out?

[blurfbreg]

Just a clue:
You can investigate if a person only use a black suitcase for example
Beastly faked investigated Kleene in killing Akonyl.
But i hope this will be taken out next game.

According to Abs.'s rule, all investigation (normal, special, fake) will seem as though someone investigated (whether it really happened or not).

"Kleene Onigiri Investigates Schillok" - True
"Kleene Onigiri Special Investigates Schillok" - True
"Kleene Onigiri Fake Investigates Schillokâ€

[Schillok]

If those wanting to play the next round of Mafia are willing to wait for my return to American soil (the 29th) I will be willing to act as GM of said round.

Are you sure you want to GM the next game? I mean... you played only one single game up to now.
Or rather: I wanted to try being a GM this time as well. There are a few things I want to try...
So, do you want to be a normal player? Or do you insist on being a GM. I mean, I enjoy playing as a player as well so if you really want to lead the next game (for example because you have good ideas), be my guest.

---

Second... well, congrats again BO on winning this round. I must admit the end was quite confusing for the town and it was easy to make mistakes there. And even then the missing vote of Kain would just have meant a draw that would likely lead to the BOs victory.
I blame the overall balancing. This was the first misslynch of the town, and it was their last. This indicates that the number of BO was slightly too high.
On the other hand, things would have gone downhill for the BO if they had lost one of their members this night instead. I think in future games the number of BO should be lower... but the amount of their APTX should be higher.

What I noticed.... town player, be more careful with your identities! It was a nice maneuver of xpon claiming to be Sherry and making the BO waste one APTX on him (Yes, they did.). But then the BO learned the identities of so many people - if they had more, they would pretty much be the only ones remaining now (beside Kain). So, be more aware and keep back your identity - or even your abilities - as long as possible. Only tell them to players you really trust, and more important: If you know about other players, DON'T TELL THEIR IDENTITIES TO A 3RD PLAYER!

[Grawwbear]

If those wanting to play the next round of Mafia are willing to wait for my return to American soil (the 29th) I will be willing to act as GM of said round.

Are you sure you want to GM the next game? I mean... you played only one single game up to now.
Or rather: I wanted to try being a GM this time as well. There are a few things I want to try...
So, do you want to be a normal player? Or do you insist on being a GM. I mean, I enjoy playing as a player as well so if you really want to lead the next game (for example because you have good ideas), be my guest.

I just want to GM one round for the heck of it. I don't think I have good ideas per se, but I just want to get the 'playing god' system out of me and then move on.

[Schillok]

If those wanting to play the next round of Mafia are willing to wait for my return to American soil (the 29th) I will be willing to act as GM of said round.

Are you sure you want to GM the next game? I mean... you played only one single game up to now.
Or rather: I wanted to try being a GM this time as well. There are a few things I want to try...
So, do you want to be a normal player? Or do you insist on being a GM. I mean, I enjoy playing as a player as well so if you really want to lead the next game (for example because you have good ideas), be my guest.

I just want to GM one round for the heck of it. I don't think I have good ideas per se, but I just want to get the 'playing god' system out of me and then move on.

So... do you want to do that next round or do you want to wait with it a bit?

[Grawwbear]

Yeah, I'll handle the next round.