Was he an interrogator?Abs. wrote:Also incorrect. I never said Tommy tried to interrogate Kain. :PPhoenixTears wrote: Hakuba then.
Mafia - Round 11 (Game Over: BO Wins)
- Yurikochan
- Conia's Wife
- Secretly in love with N...
Posts: 1254
Re: Mafia - Round 11 (Game Over: BO Wins)

Mafia: The only place where you can find Gin and Akai married together with 8 kids all disguised as Akai. Or something epic like that.
Conia wrote: Why am I thinking a ferret is an experiment from PT to mix the charm of dogs with the evilness of cats? :V

- Detective Tommy
Posts: 2465
Re: Mafia - Round 11 (Game Over: BO Wins)
Yeah, it was mostly my fault. I was too trusting of Kleene.PhoenixTears wrote:Well, see, if I had talked to you sooner, I might've been able to get Kleene out of the alliance. But since we didn't even talk until like half an hour before I died... Not much I could do.Yurikochan wrote: I never trusted Kleene, but why should someone believe a shrunken scientist?
Hakuba then.Abs. wrote: Actually Kain was not Eisuke.
In fact there was no Eisuke. I hinted to Tommy in the PM that he wasn't exactly tricked... It was just that you need to actually have people in the same country as you are if you want to interrogate them.![]()
But I will never trust anyone.. ever again.

@Abs. WTH?
How am I suppose to know that I wasn't tricked and my action failed?Abs. wrote: For some reason you were unable to accomplish your task.
Cause I assumed you were trying to make the game interesting and added storyline.
"Well, a child's curiosity and a detective's spirit of inquiry... Do have much in common, after all..." - Tooru Amuro
-
- DCTP Staff Hero
Posts: 3270
Re: Mafia - Round 11 (Game Over: BO Wins)
We have a lot of candidates for MFP this round though ::)
Your opinion is always requested in Abs.' Random Polls of Whenever
- Yurikochan
- Conia's Wife
- Secretly in love with N...
Posts: 1254
Re: Mafia - Round 11 (Game Over: BO Wins)
Kleene should be shot. ^^ GOES OFF TO KILL KLEENE IN XPON'S TOPICCtu wrote:I agree Kleene is MVPpofa wrote:No way, it worked perfectly. I sent you a PM outlining all our members and plans, knowing that you would not be able to keep yourself from posting it, thus making you look highly suspicious to Holmes, who already suspected you and was the one town vote we'd need for a win I was sick and in a hurry.
I move that we never talk about this again. *raises hand* ^^;
MVP: Kleene. She's scary.![]()

Mafia: The only place where you can find Gin and Akai married together with 8 kids all disguised as Akai. Or something epic like that.
Conia wrote: Why am I thinking a ferret is an experiment from PT to mix the charm of dogs with the evilness of cats? :V

- PT
- Community Mad Scientist
- to cammel's bav we go!
Posts: 1800
Re: Mafia - Round 11 (Game Over: BO Wins)
Since you said Tommy wasn't tricked, Kain wasn't Eisuke. Actually, I didn't think there was an Eisuke based on the fact that Tommy said he got tricked. It was something in the PM from pofa that mentioned Eisuke that made me think that. Hm. Well then, I'm stumped. Give me a minute to go down the list and I'll come up with another wild guess.Abs. wrote:Also incorrect. I never said Tommy tried to interrogate Kain.PhoenixTears wrote: Hakuba then.![]()

pofa wrote: I have never done a single thing wrong in mafia, never one lie or act of violence
- Yurikochan
- Conia's Wife
- Secretly in love with N...
Posts: 1254
Re: Mafia - Round 11 (Game Over: BO Wins)
I hope I win!Abs. wrote: We have a lot of candidates for MFP this round though ::)

Mafia: The only place where you can find Gin and Akai married together with 8 kids all disguised as Akai. Or something epic like that.
Conia wrote: Why am I thinking a ferret is an experiment from PT to mix the charm of dogs with the evilness of cats? :V

- Detective Tommy
Posts: 2465
Re: Mafia - Round 11 (Game Over: BO Wins)
+Googleplex. Let's all kill her.Yurikochan wrote:Kleene should be shot. ^^ GOES OFF TO KILL KLEENE IN XPON'S TOPICCtu wrote:I agree Kleene is MVPpofa wrote:No way, it worked perfectly. I sent you a PM outlining all our members and plans, knowing that you would not be able to keep yourself from posting it, thus making you look highly suspicious to Holmes, who already suspected you and was the one town vote we'd need for a win I was sick and in a hurry.
I move that we never talk about this again. *raises hand* ^^;
MVP: Kleene. She's scary.![]()
Spirits, UNIT!


















"Well, a child's curiosity and a detective's spirit of inquiry... Do have much in common, after all..." - Tooru Amuro
- Detective Tommy
Posts: 2465
Re: Mafia - Round 11 (Game Over: BO Wins)
Want me to tell you who it was?PhoenixTears wrote:Since you said Tommy wasn't tricked, Kain wasn't Eisuke. Actually, I didn't think there was an Eisuke based on the fact that Tommy said he got tricked. It was something in the PM from pofa that mentioned Eisuke that made me think that. Hm. Well then, I'm stumped. Give me a minute to go down the list and I'll come up with another wild guess.Abs. wrote:Also incorrect. I never said Tommy tried to interrogate Kain.PhoenixTears wrote: Hakuba then.![]()
![]()
"Well, a child's curiosity and a detective's spirit of inquiry... Do have much in common, after all..." - Tooru Amuro
-
- DCTP Staff Hero
Posts: 3270
Re: Mafia - Round 11 (Game Over: BO Wins)
I couldn't just tell you "Hey you can't interrogate Commi because she's not in Japan yet." And it is stated in the rules that no actions may be taken on players who are not in Japan/in transit (except discombobulate, which can confuse the traveler so that he or she misses the flight)Detective Tommy wrote:How am I suppose to know that I wasn't tricked and my action failed?Abs. wrote: For some reason you were unable to accomplish your task.
Cause I assumed you were trying to make the game interesting and added storyline.
Anyhow, don't worry. The BO thought there was an Eisuke in the game as well.
Your opinion is always requested in Abs.' Random Polls of Whenever
- Detective Tommy
Posts: 2465
Re: Mafia - Round 11 (Game Over: BO Wins)
Seriously Abs.
I think you should post whether I'm tricked or the action failed.
It says that if I'm discombobulated, I will get PM'ed saying my action failed.
And I got a PM saying my action failed.
If the action doesn't work for a reason = "Your action failed"
If I'm discombobulated, can you say "You were discombobulated"
I think you should post whether I'm tricked or the action failed.
It says that if I'm discombobulated, I will get PM'ed saying my action failed.
And I got a PM saying my action failed.
If the action doesn't work for a reason = "Your action failed"
If I'm discombobulated, can you say "You were discombobulated"
"Well, a child's curiosity and a detective's spirit of inquiry... Do have much in common, after all..." - Tooru Amuro
-
- DCTP Staff Hero
Posts: 3270
Re: Mafia - Round 11 (Game Over: BO Wins)
Incorrect. It says in the rules that if you were discombobulated, you would be notified that your action failed.
Your opinion is always requested in Abs.' Random Polls of Whenever
- PT
- Community Mad Scientist
- to cammel's bav we go!
Posts: 1800
Re: Mafia - Round 11 (Game Over: BO Wins)
It wasn't any of the police officers because you murdered all of them in the End Game post. Possibly Kazuha or Araide? I know xpon mentioned something about "Kazuha's charm" at some point but I don't know if he actually knew Kain's role and was basing it off that or because he's xpon and comes up with wild theories without any encouragement.

No, see, now I wanna figure it out myself.Detective Tommy wrote:Want me to tell you who it was?PhoenixTears wrote:Since you said Tommy wasn't tricked, Kain wasn't Eisuke. Actually, I didn't think there was an Eisuke based on the fact that Tommy said he got tricked. It was something in the PM from pofa that mentioned Eisuke that made me think that. Hm. Well then, I'm stumped. Give me a minute to go down the list and I'll come up with another wild guess.Abs. wrote:Also incorrect. I never said Tommy tried to interrogate Kain.PhoenixTears wrote: Hakuba then.![]()
![]()

pofa wrote: I have never done a single thing wrong in mafia, never one lie or act of violence
- pofa
- Community Savior
- Armchair sorcerey
Posts: 1183
Re: Mafia - Round 11 (Game Over: BO Wins)
Laurell thought he knew. Although he didn't tell us until last phase.PhoenixTears wrote: It wasn't any of the police officers because you murdered all of them in the End Game post. Possibly Kazuha or Araide? I know xpon mentioned something about "Kazuha's charm" at some point but I don't know if he actually knew Kain's role and was basing it off that or because he's xpon and comes up with wild theories without any encouragement.
No, see, now I wanna figure it out myself.Detective Tommy wrote:Want me to tell you who it was?PhoenixTears wrote:Since you said Tommy wasn't tricked, Kain wasn't Eisuke. Actually, I didn't think there was an Eisuke based on the fact that Tommy said he got tricked. It was something in the PM from pofa that mentioned Eisuke that made me think that. Hm. Well then, I'm stumped. Give me a minute to go down the list and I'll come up with another wild guess.Abs. wrote:Also incorrect. I never said Tommy tried to interrogate Kain.PhoenixTears wrote: Hakuba then.![]()
![]()
![]()

So there was no Yumi after all.



Superman = Captain America > Aquaman = Hal Jordan > Wonder Woman > Barry Allen > Thor > Martian Manhunter > The Hulk > Wasp > Hawkeye > [power gap] > Iron Man = Batman > [power gap] > Hank Pym
- Detective Tommy
Posts: 2465
Re: Mafia - Round 11 (Game Over: BO Wins)
It wasn't a statement.Abs. wrote: Incorrect. It says in the rules that if you were discombobulated, you would be notified that your action failed.
It was a request. As in, if I'm discombobulated, can you say "You were discombobulated."
I forgot to put a question mark.
Are you trying to figure out Kain's role? Or are you trying to figure out who I interrogated on Night 1? As in, who Hakuba is..?PhoenixTears wrote: It wasn't any of the police officers because you murdered all of them in the End Game post. Possibly Kazuha or Araide? I know xpon mentioned something about "Kazuha's charm" at some point but I don't know if he actually knew Kain's role and was basing it off that or because he's xpon and comes up with wild theories without any encouragement.
No, see, now I wanna figure it out myself.Detective Tommy wrote:Want me to tell you who it was?PhoenixTears wrote:Since you said Tommy wasn't tricked, Kain wasn't Eisuke. Actually, I didn't think there was an Eisuke based on the fact that Tommy said he got tricked. It was something in the PM from pofa that mentioned Eisuke that made me think that. Hm. Well then, I'm stumped. Give me a minute to go down the list and I'll come up with another wild guess.Abs. wrote:Also incorrect. I never said Tommy tried to interrogate Kain.PhoenixTears wrote: Hakuba then.![]()
![]()
![]()
"Well, a child's curiosity and a detective's spirit of inquiry... Do have much in common, after all..." - Tooru Amuro
- blurfbreg
Posts: 356
Re: Mafia - Round 11 (Game Over: BO Wins)
I wanted to trust Kleene, but nothing she did with me made any sense, and made me suspect her MORE and MORE. Unfortunately, MANY OTHER PEOPLE already had to spill my role to EVERYONE ELSE, so it didn't matter how I played. By the time pofa sent out the PM to (in a sense) everyone, I knew the game ended for townies. Told Tommy and xpon to go with my idea, which would have taken care of Kleene. (Sorry to make you sound evil, Kleene)

Sleep tight; Don't let the bedbugs bite.