conia wrote:
And another issue:
There's TOO much ghost-talk going on, and not only in this thread. Can we decrease that, please?
...
No talk in here or in any thread. Seriously, I got info out of ghost comments and verified it as true.
Ctu wrote:
Abs. wrote:
I agree. Ghost-talk actually helps the B.O. more than anything, by scrolling pertinent information too quickly, before it has the chance to be fully examined. I'm calling the next game as far as GMing (hope it's not too early), and this will be covered in my version of the rules.
(Btw I'm not a ghost, so.)
agreed so please limit what you say dead people the living should not have to carry around ouija boards all the time
There is already a rule that says that ghost may speak but they may not talk about mafia related stuff that could reveal infos! And no one can check if people aren't PMing each others anyway....
But most people hate this kind of "cheating" anyway. So if you PM someone as a ghost with info, you could be yelled at from that person anyway.
And I know it's hard to hold back your own suspicion or infos you gathered. But that's also why the "will" thing was put in. So you can put down infos there (like I and others did) and anything else, other infos you forgot to mention or your suspicions can't be said anymore!
I even hold back on "trash-talk" which I thought could be interpreted as info from the alive players, even tho I don't know anything about that matter I wanted to say ;p
Detective Tommy wrote:
Agreed, all the dead talk drowns out the important post.
True, but so does the "off-topic" talk from the alive people.
If you want the ghosts to shut up then you'd also need the alive people to shut up and stay "on topic". But if you do that then the alive people can't make "hints" which look like "off-topic" talk, which isn't
And also, if you don't want Ghosts to talk in other threads about mafia, you need to extend that to the alive people too!
I find it silly that people give out "infos" in other threads beside mafia anyway.
So basically, let the ghost talk, but they have to follow the rules anyway. So there shouldn't be any giving out of infos/hint anyway!
