SAMT: Round 15 - Mafia Historical Statistics Table up until

[PT]

Or we could just have the GM give Seb the list of inactive people after each round, and they don't get credit for playing on the table.

That almost seems like letting them off too easy.

Anyway, the table isn't my issue with it.

[pofa]

Or we could just have the GM give Seb the list of inactive people after each round, and they don't get credit for playing on the table.

That almost seems like letting them off too easy.

Anyway, the table isn't my issue with it.

It looked like it was Abs.'s issue, though.

So maybe they wouldn't be allowed to play the next round? Any in-game punishment runs the risk of hurting the person's teammates for something they didn't do. If Beastly (just to use an example) had been forced to flee/had his role given out/been killed every time he was BO, it would have been sorta bad for them. And it's not fair to give the BO a free kill when a townie's inactive either.

[Abs.]

And it's not fair to give the BO a free kill when a townie's inactive either.

That happened with Holmes 

[PT]

So maybe they wouldn't be allowed to play the next round? Any in-game punishment runs the risk of hurting the person's teammates for something they didn't do. If Beastly (just to use an example) had been forced to flee/had his role given out/been killed every time he was BO, it would have been sorta bad for them. And it's not fair to give the BO a free kill when a townie's inactive either.

I think that's what we talked about originally though, and Kleene doesn't want to ban them from this round. So I'd say the best thing to do right now would be to let them play (or not play, as tends to be the case) if they sign up, then deal with it or whatever next round.

And it's not fair to give the BO a free kill when a townie's inactive either.

That happened with Holmes 

If you're talking about Round 14, when Holmes fled, it didn't make much of a difference because town won anyway (by quite a bit). If you mean in Round 15, I actually don't remember this.

[pofa]

And it's not fair to give the BO a free kill when a townie's inactive either.

That happened with Holmes  >:(

Yeah, it really messed you guys up too.

But that is what I was thinking of.

[xpon]

what if being inactive is someone playing style...

we cant force everyone to be a chatterbox like me.....

[pofa]

what if being inactive is someone playing style...

we cant force everyone to be a chatterbox like me.....

I wasn't think of people who don't talk. I was thinking of people who don't send in actions/lynch votes.

[PT]

what if being inactive is someone playing style...

we cant force everyone to be a chatterbox like me.....

Being inactive isn't the same as being quiet. There are some people who don't say a whole lot in the thread or in PMs, doesn't make them inactive. They're still doing actions and stuff.

[xpon]

OH!! sorry then...

i mix it up..

well.. dont vote is an option too right?

[PT]

OH!! sorry then...

i mix it up..

well.. dont vote is an option too right?

Yeah, I mean some people don't vote during certain phases (like Day 1), but that doesn't mean they never vote or send actions, either. And not sending actions + not voting at all = inactive, imo. (Why do I feel like I'm repeating myself over and over here? )

[xpon]

because i am teasing you!!!.

well.. being inactive and get arrested is better then killed like holmes (round 14)

and can we have a statistic of who got first day lynched most... who died in night 1 most..ect....

[Akonyl]

And it's not fair to give the BO a free kill when a townie's inactive either.

That happened with Holmes  >:(

If you're talking about Round 14, when Holmes fled, it didn't make much of a difference because town won anyway (by quite a bit). If you mean in Round 15, I actually don't remember this.

doutb he means 15, because I took care of lynching holmes the first day

[PT]

Holmes didn't die, he fled. (Cause that really makes such a big difference! )

....I have a feeling having that statistic would make people try to get a certain person to have the highest score.

doutb he means 15, because I took care of lynching holmes the first day

I didn't pay a whole lot of attention to what happened when during Round 15, tbh. I didn't even bother writing down lynch votes til after the round ended. (And only because that info is very, very important. At least to me. )

[xpon]

well.. you already got 2 point for nigt 1 victime.. Fiinei-chan

[PT]

well.. you already got 2 point for nigt 1 victime.. Fiinei-chan

Nope - if you're only counting regular mafia, I only would have 1 point. If you're including mini mafia, it's 3.