Detective Tommy wrote:
Wait, so why did you trust James Rye? What did he tell you?
(Sorry if you already said it, but I might have missed it..)
Pretty much every argument I made about conia being B.O. was a valid one.
Because he took a huge gamble to trust James Rye on no basis whatsoever (besides his own idea that I was B.O. and framing James Rye), and honestly it wasn't his playing style to trust so blindly. I suspected it was a trap for like 5 phases LOL
Commi-Ninja wrote:
I admit I didn't trust conia until the phase after James Rye and Detective Tommy died. I was convinced he was Vermouth disguised as a police officer.
Him trusting James Rye was the only reason I thought he was BO.
But he said he could investigate, so I assumed he was Vermouth as a investigator.
"Well, a child's curiosity and a detective's spirit of inquiry... Do have much in common, after all..." - Tooru Amuro
Commi-Ninja wrote:
I admit I didn't trust conia until the phase after James Rye and Detective Tommy died. I was convinced he was Vermouth disguised as a police officer.
Him trusting James Rye was the only reason I thought he was BO.
But he said he could investigate, so I assumed he was Vermouth as a investigator.
Yep, and we had been talking at that time, so I was in agreement with you. It was only after you died and I started talking to him that I believed conia was actually a police officer. And it was so easy at that point to discover that Holmes was Akemi.
Ctu wrote:
conia wrote:
Detective Tommy wrote:
Sorry Conia.
I really thought you were BO because you kept helping James Rye (claiming James Black)
When I was James.
Who wouldn't?
How did you find out Ninja stole from me and when?
I told him.
Hey, by the way, I DID steal a gun and glasses from you.
3DS FC: 4699-5851-2068
I might wake up early and go running. I also might wake up and win the lottery. The odds are about the same.
Commi-Ninja wrote:
I admit I didn't trust conia until the phase after James Rye and Detective Tommy died. I was convinced he was Vermouth disguised as a police officer.
Him trusting James Rye was the only reason I thought he was BO.
But he said he could investigate, so I assumed he was Vermouth as a investigator.
Yep, and we had been talking at that time, so I was in agreement with you. It was only after you died and I started talking to him that I believed conia was actually a police officer. And it was so easy at that point to discover that Holmes was Akemi.
Ctu wrote:
conia wrote:
Detective Tommy wrote:
Sorry Conia.
I really thought you were BO because you kept helping James Rye (claiming James Black)
When I was James.
Who wouldn't?
How did you find out Ninja stole from me and when?
I told him.
Hey, by the way, I DID steal a gun and glasses from you.
When was it...was it long before you died or was it after?
Kleene Onigiri wrote:
Mafia: Where you fight with unicorns and puppies as your weapons.
Commi-Ninja wrote:
I admit I didn't trust conia until the phase after James Rye and Detective Tommy died. I was convinced he was Vermouth disguised as a police officer.
Him trusting James Rye was the only reason I thought he was BO.
But he said he could investigate, so I assumed he was Vermouth as a investigator.
Yep, and we had been talking at that time, so I was in agreement with you. It was only after you died and I started talking to him that I believed conia was actually a police officer. And it was so easy at that point to discover that Holmes was Akemi.
How did you know he was a cop after I died?
"Well, a child's curiosity and a detective's spirit of inquiry... Do have much in common, after all..." - Tooru Amuro
Commi-Ninja wrote:
I admit I didn't trust conia until the phase after James Rye and Detective Tommy died. I was convinced he was Vermouth disguised as a police officer.
So was I. I thought he made the arrest on the first day knowing it would fail (because he didn't care about being suspended ) in order to make JR and the rest of us trust him. But then JR and Detective Tommy both claimed to me be James within an hour of one another, and it didn't seem like conia and Detective Tommy were working together, and conia couldn't give a valid reason for trusting JR (which surely he would have if it had been a BO plan). But then I thought it was possible that Abs. was Eisuke and I'd gotten him arrested by Vermouth by telling everyone I'd been tricked that second night. (Although I didn't want that to be true because I wanted Abs. to be Vodka. And on the note, neither "A" word sounded like Eisuke. )
Could Vermouth really arrest Eisuke or Kid if she's disguised as a policeman? Like, if she'd found out beyond doubt that Commi-Ninja was Kid, would Commi have been arrested automatically?
Superman = Captain America > Aquaman = Hal Jordan > Wonder Woman > Barry Allen > Thor > Martian Manhunter > The Hulk > Wasp > Hawkeye > [power gap] > Iron Man = Batman > [power gap] > Hank Pym
Commi-Ninja wrote:
I admit I didn't trust conia until the phase after James Rye and Detective Tommy died. I was convinced he was Vermouth disguised as a police officer.
Him trusting James Rye was the only reason I thought he was BO.
But he said he could investigate, so I assumed he was Vermouth as a investigator.
Yep, and we had been talking at that time, so I was in agreement with you. It was only after you died and I started talking to him that I believed conia was actually a police officer. And it was so easy at that point to discover that Holmes was Akemi.
Ctu wrote:
conia wrote:
Detective Tommy wrote:
Sorry Conia.
I really thought you were BO because you kept helping James Rye (claiming James Black)
When I was James.
Who wouldn't?
How did you find out Ninja stole from me and when?
I told him.
Hey, by the way, I DID steal a gun and glasses from you.
BTW.. if you stole some thing... you cant tell that to the tread right comni? only to you and your allies that not police.. because you'll get arrested right?
xpon is so cute...
Even Ayumi~chan and Sera~chan love to hug him.....
) in order to make JR and the rest of us trust him. But then JR and Detective Tommy both claimed to me be James within an hour of one another, and it didn't seem like conia and Detective Tommy were working together, and conia couldn't give a valid reason for trusting JR (which surely he would have if it had been a BO plan). But then I thought it was possible that Abs. was Eisuke and I'd gotten him arrested by Vermouth by telling everyone I'd been tricked that second night. (Although I didn't want that to be true because I wanted Abs. to be Vodka. And on the note, neither "A" word sounded like Eisuke. 
