DCTP Forums

Time to vote for the best of the best...of the best! Twice!

Last year I had a similar topic, but regardless of how fair it was, the London case overshadowed EVERYTHING. I still find that a bit questionable if many people listened to what I meant so I will repeat myself.

This is only looking at these cases as the cases/mysteries on their own. Character and plot stuff, outside of how they affect the case specifically, should not be relevant to your decision.

I will see, while there were still good cases this year, last year kinda feels like a fluke where there were 3-4 cases that you could argue were some of the best since the first few years of the series. Nothing this year was as good as the Demon Dog case and nothing was as important to people as the London case.

also no one cares about 1 episode AOs so none of that

Now with 2 votes, I will vote for the Confinement case and West vs. East. The Confinement case as a murder mystery is just ok, but how it's presented and how much it surprised me as a case in this series really made me enjoy it. As a case, it had a lot of clever twists and while Shinichi's solution to prevent anyone from dying was hilariously simple, it was kinda brilliant and one of those things you smirk at because you figure out what's going on only 15 seconds before it's revealed.

West vs. East was just really fun even without the Heiji and Conan rivalry thing (though I would count the scene where Conan intentionally tries to speak Kansai-ben since it's how they definitively confirm who the culprit is). It's simply just a really well done case, which is odd since I often find cases heavily relying on the japanese language to be pretty boring. Just really good pacing and a fun little mystery and everything works really well for what it is.

While 2012's anime cases may not have had cases as genius as some of the ones in 2011, they were consistently good and entertaining, and so picking two is actually very hard. I'm just glad the 600's didn't experience a drop in quality in its second half like the 500's did.

Kogoro-san is a Good Man was pretty original and the 1-hour special was hilarious, those are close seconds. The Wedding Eve case I was tempted to pick for its audacity. In the end I picked the Confinement case and the EYE case; both had pretty good twists in the cases.

Honestly, I really wish I liked the Illusion case more. I don't remember what but something about it really prevented it from being nearly as enjoyable as the previous 2 cases with Yamato Kansuke.

Could be that despite being a good case, it was less exciting than the previous two with Kansuke and he only had a relatively minor role this time around.

Kudo Shinchi wrote: Could be that despite being a good case, it was less exciting than the previous two with Kansuke and he only had a relatively minor role this time around.

yeah, but I felt like something was just off or uninteresting about it just from the case itself. I don't even particularly remember what though.