Gin vs. Ran: Who is smarter?

Versus polls and this-or-that contests should find themselves in here.
Post Reply

Gin vs. Ran: Who is smarter?

Gin
58
76%
Ran
18
24%
 
Total votes: 76
kholoudsafir

Posts:
1111

Re: Gin vs. Ran: Who is smarter?

Post by kholoudsafir »

sstimson wrote:
xpon wrote:
Abs. wrote:
kirite wrote: Gin will be all like "pfft kids don't shrink my super logical genius brain says so".  And Ran will be all like "pfft kids don't shrink it's not like this is an anime with mythical drugs that shrink people".  Then Shiho and Shinichi will unshrink infront of their eyes and they'll be too distracted by naked Shiho to see Shinichi transform.  So therefore neither of them will ever know.  They're fools forever bwahahaha.
I only make topics like this to see what you will post, dear kirite.  <3
so .. all of us is just an EXTRA ?
But TWICE Ran made the connection and Mastermind Conan need to find a way to use a trick to fool Ran. And the first Time she almost nailed it!
conia wrote: Ran, of course. Gin couldn't have guessed Conan's PIN password 8)

who does not like kirite posts  ;)

actually she figured out three times, the last time was more like suspicion similar to the first time, eps. 398-400 it was also dead funny too. However, you are right in the second time she did not take what Yukiko told her and from that ep. 96 until " desperate revival" she was convinced, but waiting for him to tell her.

good one Conia  ;D
Every time I want to give up on DC, it manages to bring me back, it brings me back feelings I know that I will never ever feel or live again.
Cider
Community Evil Overlord

Posts:
385

Re: Gin vs. Ran: Who is smarter?

Post by Cider »

LOL Gin is obviously smarter in other fields.
But I think Ran will find out first lol :P and she'll freak out and be like "WTF SHINICHI YOU'VE BEEN BATHING WITH ME FOR ALL THOSE DAYS?"
And her screams get to Vodka, who will be like: "What? Shinichi Kudo? but we killed him..."
and then he tells Gin. That's when he figures LOL xD
User avatar
Chekhov MacGuffin
Community Scholar
BAGA BGEGD EDBDEG A

Posts:
2684

Re: Gin vs. Ran: Who is smarter?

Post by Chekhov MacGuffin »

Cider wrote: LOL Gin is obviously smarter in other fields.
But I think Ran will find out first lol :P and she'll freak out and be like "WTF SHINICHI YOU'VE BEEN BATHING WITH ME FOR ALL THOSE DAYS?"
And her screams get to Vodka, who will be like: "What? Shinichi Kudo? but we killed him..."
and then he tells Gin. That's when he figures LOL xD
For some incredibly messed up reason even I can't fathom, when I first read your post I thought you said Gin and Vodka were bathing with Ran. I have no idea how I managed to do that because your post is sensibly worded. In any case, it was too late to stop me from imagining Gin, Vodka, and Ran in a bath together. OTL. GinxRan .... that would be a crack pairing from hell. Poor Shinichi, his crush consorting with his worst enemy. He might actually be driven to murder.
User avatar
Misztina

Posts:
976
Contact:

Re: Gin vs. Ran: Who is smarter?

Post by Misztina »

Ran. She has driven the best detective of Japan in the corner 4 times already!

And Gin was stupid for running away in episode 1, without being 100% sure that Shinichi died.
User avatar
ziraulo
Finally broke that Lurking Spell...

Posts:
682
Contact:

Re: Gin vs. Ran: Who is smarter?

Post by ziraulo »

Misztina wrote: Ran. She has driven the best detective of Japan in the corner 4 times already!

And Gin was stupid for running away in episode 1, without being 100% sure that Shinichi died.
I agree with Misztina. Ran doesn't realize her potential, though. If I were her, I'd use the puppy-dog eyes against Shinichi or make his guilt kill him faster.
Spoiler:
They hatched!!! I'm a mom!!!!

Image Image Image

My tumblr: http://ziraulo.tumblr.com/

3DS Friend Code: 0189-9300-8351
Kor
Administrator

Posts:
3051

Re: Gin vs. Ran: Who is smarter?

Post by Kor »

Chekhov MacGuffin wrote:
Cider wrote: LOL Gin is obviously smarter in other fields.
But I think Ran will find out first lol :P and she'll freak out and be like "WTF SHINICHI YOU'VE BEEN BATHING WITH ME FOR ALL THOSE DAYS?"
And her screams get to Vodka, who will be like: "What? Shinichi Kudo? but we killed him..."
and then he tells Gin. That's when he figures LOL xD
For some incredibly messed up reason even I can't fathom, when I first read your post I thought you said Gin and Vodka were bathing with Ran. I have no idea how I managed to do that because your post is sensibly worded. In any case, it was too late to stop me from imagining Gin, Vodka, and Ran in a bath together. OTL. GinxRan .... that would be a crack pairing from hell. Poor Shinichi, his crush consorting with his worst enemy. He might actually be driven to murder.
Obviously, the fact that Vodka and Gin were in tropical land in the exact same day with Ran and Shinichi, wasn't a coincidence  ;)
Image
Nyarl
Lost Detective

Posts:
670

Re: Gin vs. Ran: Who is smarter?

Post by Nyarl »

Likelihood and rapidity of forming valid theories about the mysteries, with some skew for intellect noted in back story: Yusaku>=Heizo>=Koumei>Shin'ichi>=Bourbon=Shuichi=Okiya>=Hattori>=Yamato>=Hakuba>=Gin>=Eri>=Ai>Eisuke=Ran=Sato=Uehara=Chousuke Takagi>Wataru Takagi>=Shiratori=James>Sango Yokomizo=Yuminaga=Jodie=Matsumoto>Juugo Yokomizo>Sonoko>Megure=Kogoro=Yumi=Mitsuhiko=Yukiko>=Agasa>Chiba=Camel=Vodka=Chianti>=Korn=Ayumi>Genta>Yamamura

">=" means I'm ambivalent but giving the edge to the character on the left.

Agasa's just too useless in investigations for his engineering skills to skew higher. Even Yukiko can parrot the truth without much help with the bow-tie. Senility, I suppose (he's not that old, though), or just being stuck as the Watson. (It'd be fun if he figured out a Kiichimon contraption mechanically before Conan could figure out the riddles.)

I have no good sense of where Vermouth goes in that. Probably Ran/Sato level, possibly smarter than Gin though (she would have gotten Ai and Jodie if Ran and Shuichi hadn't interfered).  

Gin would drop if it's ever proven he somehow didn't hear Conan in the locker. (No, not killing Conan isn't proof. Suspecting a kid was being used by someone and deciding to follow the kid back to that person is smarter than just killing the kid. Conan just got lucky he lost consciousness and got lost in a crowd later.) He'd still be ahead of the likes of the mediocre police like Juugo and certainly dumb-asses like Megure. Remember, the plan to return Kir to the Org. relied on Gin actually being pretty smart, and he still thought it was too easy.

James would be Eri/Yamato level if he hadn't idiotically kept Camel with the FBI after the Org. saw him "die" in an explosion. (Remember, he anticipated Conan's plan to rescue him.)

Sonoko almost had the Mystery in the Net trick solved.

Jodie would be Ran level if she were giving Conan hints in Concealed with Abbreviation (doesn't seem likely given her later performances).
Last edited by Nyarl on May 27th, 2010, 9:37 am, edited 1 time in total.
é»’ã
ccppfan
I'm bluek's pet cat <3

Posts:
1165

Re: Gin vs. Ran: Who is smarter?

Post by ccppfan »

Gin... of course.

He IS older. And a bad guy.

Everyone knows that the bad guys are always clever.

... okay most of the time.
User avatar
Conia
Yurikochan's Husband
Conan Shuuichi

Posts:
5194

Re: Gin vs. Ran: Who is smarter?

Post by Conia »

ccppfan wrote: Gin... of course.

He IS older. And a bad guy.

Everyone knows that the bad guys are always clever.

... okay most of the time.
We're back to Yusaku being the BO Boss?? ;D
Image
Cider
Community Evil Overlord

Posts:
385

Re: Gin vs. Ran: Who is smarter?

Post by Cider »

Chekhov MacGuffin wrote:
Cider wrote: LOL Gin is obviously smarter in other fields.
But I think Ran will find out first lol :P and she'll freak out and be like "WTF SHINICHI YOU'VE BEEN BATHING WITH ME FOR ALL THOSE DAYS?"
And her screams get to Vodka, who will be like: "What? Shinichi Kudo? but we killed him..."
and then he tells Gin. That's when he figures LOL xD
For some incredibly messed up reason even I can't fathom, when I first read your post I thought you said Gin and Vodka were bathing with Ran. I have no idea how I managed to do that because your post is sensibly worded. In any case, it was too late to stop me from imagining Gin, Vodka, and Ran in a bath together. OTL. GinxRan .... that would be a crack pairing from hell. Poor Shinichi, his crush consorting with his worst enemy. He might actually be driven to murder.
OMG I was laughing like hell. Bathing? xDDDDDD
You really ARE naughty, Chev. haha .
GinxRan? That would be kinda odd xDDD especially in a bath with Vodka.
Detective Prince

Re: Gin vs. Ran: Who is smarter?

Post by Detective Prince »

Gin by far...
conia wrote: Ran, of course. Gin couldn't have guessed Conan's PIN password 8)
It was Shinichi's phone wasn't it?

And I'm sure it was such a test of her Intelligenceto figure out that SHERLOCK HOLMES FREAK's pin
User avatar
Commi-Ninja

Posts:
1583

Re: Gin vs. Ran: Who is smarter?

Post by Commi-Ninja »

Cider wrote:
Chekhov MacGuffin wrote:
Cider wrote: LOL Gin is obviously smarter in other fields.
But I think Ran will find out first lol :P and she'll freak out and be like "WTF SHINICHI YOU'VE BEEN BATHING WITH ME FOR ALL THOSE DAYS?"
And her screams get to Vodka, who will be like: "What? Shinichi Kudo? but we killed him..."
and then he tells Gin. That's when he figures LOL xD
For some incredibly messed up reason even I can't fathom, when I first read your post I thought you said Gin and Vodka were bathing with Ran. I have no idea how I managed to do that because your post is sensibly worded. In any case, it was too late to stop me from imagining Gin, Vodka, and Ran in a bath together. OTL. GinxRan .... that would be a crack pairing from hell. Poor Shinichi, his crush consorting with his worst enemy. He might actually be driven to murder.
OMG I was laughing like hell. Bathing? xDDDDDD
You really ARE naughty, Chev. haha .
GinxRan? That would be kinda odd xDDD especially in a bath with Vodka.
I think that situation would require copious amounts of vodka to ever occur.  ;D
3DS FC: 4699-5851-2068
I might wake up early and go running. I also might wake up and win the lottery. The odds are about the same.
User avatar
Conia
Yurikochan's Husband
Conan Shuuichi

Posts:
5194

Re: Gin vs. Ran: Who is smarter?

Post by Conia »

Detective Prince wrote: Gin by far...
conia wrote: Ran, of course. Gin couldn't have guessed Conan's PIN password 8)
It was Shinichi's phone wasn't it?

And I'm sure it was such a test of her Intelligenceto figure out that SHERLOCK HOLMES FREAK's pin
Conan had it, but you're right. Ran wouldn't have guessed the PIN if she thought it was Conan's cellphone imo.
Image
Nyarl
Lost Detective

Posts:
670

Re: Gin vs. Ran: Who is smarter?

Post by Nyarl »

Detective Prince wrote: Gin by far...
conia wrote: Ran, of course. Gin couldn't have guessed Conan's PIN password 8)
It was Shinichi's phone wasn't it?

And I'm sure it was such a test of her Intelligenceto figure out that SHERLOCK HOLMES FREAK's pin
How is Gin smarter "by far"? Not many characters solve cases without Conan's help or can parallel his thinking. Ran was one of them, so she's actually ahead of Haibara in practice (no, looking for a pattern on a map or recognizing the gender of a corpse aren't nearly as impressive as a multi-step deduction). Only reason I didn't put Ran ahead of Haibara was the same reason I put Eri ahead of Ran, back story asserted intelligence (no Harvard scholarships or wonder drug research for Ran yet).
Last edited by Nyarl on May 27th, 2010, 11:36 am, edited 1 time in total.
é»’ã
kentasaiba
Mr. Pickles!

Posts:
584

Re: Gin vs. Ran: Who is smarter?

Post by kentasaiba »

ok
Gin:
Helicoter-Pilot
Sniper-education
Secret-Agent training
probably martial-arts training
ect.

Ran:
Well... its Ran, she would win.
Image
Post Reply