Kindly read/watch both adaptations before voting. As for FMA: Brotherhood, it's not finished yet, so just read the manga to know the story.
Option #1: It was the first anime adaptation of Fullmetal Alchemist. It was the one with the movie and its story is already finished.
Spoiler:
- where Ed and Al went to Earth
- the half of the series follows the manga; the other half doesn't
- where sloth is a woman
- where pride is king bradley
- where selim is just a normal kid [not a homunculus]
anyways, here's the movie poster:
Option #2: It was the new anime adaptation of Fullmetal Alchemist and it just started airing last month. It's also based on the manga.
Spoiler:
- where they went to briggs
- where scar killed winry's parents
- where Ed and AL went to Briggs
- Where Maria Ross was suspected to be Hughes' murderer
- with Lin Yao, Ran Fan, and Mei Chan
promo pic:
After reading, vote, or watch/read both adaptations then vote.
Re: FMA poll
Posted: May 26th, 2009, 12:39 pm
by FourteenTwelve
I prefer the first anime, because I love the soundtrack, the voice actors (especially Mustang), the style of drawing and animation. The plot is also very good, even though it's different from the plot of the manga.
I've watched the two first episodes of Brotherhood, and I don't like the style of drawing as much as the one in the first anime. It's good that it'll follow the plot of the manga more closely, but I still currently prefer the first anime. ...but this opinion may change as the Brotherhood series goes on.
Re: FMA poll
Posted: May 26th, 2009, 12:45 pm
by LDCF
FourteenTwelve wrote:
I've watched the two first episodes of Brotherhood, and I don't like the style of drawing as much as the one in the first anime.
I agree.
Edward's hair in Brotherhood made me uncomfortable. xD
But Brotherhod's plot is cooler for me.
Re: FMA poll
Posted: May 26th, 2009, 11:22 pm
by bluekaitou1412
Don't know much about FMA Brotherhood.. It only aired recently in my country...
But FMA Original is the best!
Re: FMA poll
Posted: May 27th, 2009, 12:04 am
by GinRei
bluekaitou1412 wrote:
Don't know much about FMA Brotherhood.. It only aired recently in my country...
It only just recently started airing everywhere. Within the last two months.
However, soon the awesomeness of Brotherhood shall become obvious. Once the new characters start showing up.
Re: FMA poll
Posted: May 27th, 2009, 3:39 am
by LDCF
GinRei wrote:
soon the awesomeness of Brotherhood shall become obvious. Once the new characters start showing up.
YEAH! \m/
like . . .
Spoiler:
Armstrong's sister
Ling
Ran Fan old man Fu
Mei Chan
her pet - forgot her name xD
Kimbley's men [Ed gave nicknames for them like donkey kong, etc. XDD]
Father - the head of the homunculus
and many more.
Re: FMA poll
Posted: May 27th, 2009, 11:09 am
by GinRei
LDCF wrote:
Spoiler:
Armstrong's sister
Father - the head of the homunculus
Technically...
Spoiler:
Father already appeared. He had brief 1-2 second shots in the first episode, and Lust has mentioned him by name once or twice as well.
Re: FMA poll
Posted: May 27th, 2009, 12:31 pm
by kkslider5552000
where's the I don't care about FMA option
Re: FMA poll
Posted: May 27th, 2009, 12:34 pm
by sdf1macross
kkslider5552000 wrote:
where's the I don't care about FMA option
Yeah, we need that option too
Re: FMA poll
Posted: May 30th, 2009, 7:48 am
by LDCF
sdf1macross wrote:
kkslider5552000 wrote:
where's the I don't care about FMA option
Yeah, we need that option too
haha!
It's a bit late, you know, but oh well.
there you go~ XDD
Re: FMA poll
Posted: May 30th, 2009, 6:05 pm
by kirite
FourteenTwelve wrote:
I prefer the first anime, because I love the soundtrack, the voice actors (especially Mustang), the style of drawing and animation. The plot is also very good, even though it's different from the plot of the manga.
I've watched the two first episodes of Brotherhood, and I don't like the style of drawing as much as the one in the first anime. It's good that it'll follow the plot of the manga more closely, but I still currently prefer the first anime. ...but this opinion may change as the Brotherhood series goes on.
I liked the soundtrack and style of the first anime as well. But then when they deviated from the manga it was like . I guess I like the manga better but I like the first anime more...I wonder if that makes sense?
I love Lust's VA in the first one @.@.
Re: FMA poll
Posted: June 4th, 2009, 5:38 am
by tanteiconan1603
FourteenTwelve wrote:
I prefer the first anime, because I love the soundtrack, the voice actors (especially Mustang), the style of drawing and animation. The plot is also very good, even though it's different from the plot of the manga.
I've watched the two first episodes of Brotherhood, and I don't like the style of drawing as much as the one in the first anime.
Yeah, your right. I love the first original anime of FMA. The drawings are so cool, I love them. Alphonse, (especially as a child) is so cute . Riza Hawkeye is pretty on FMA too.
Re: FMA poll
Posted: October 23rd, 2009, 12:08 pm
by tanteiconan1603
FourteenTwelve wrote:
I prefer the first anime, because I love the soundtrack, the voice actors (especially Mustang), the style of drawing and animation. The plot is also very good, even though it's different from the plot of the manga.
I've watched the two first episodes of Brotherhood, and I don't like the style of drawing as much as the one in the first anime. It's good that it'll follow the plot of the manga more closely, but I still currently prefer the first anime. ...but this opinion may change as the Brotherhood series goes on.
Yah. I agree on you.
I hate the BROTHERHOOD one.
The drawing makes me sick.
I also hate the BROTHERHOOD's voice actors.
Re: FMA poll
Posted: October 26th, 2009, 6:34 am
by nanilola
tanteiconan1603 wrote:
I also hate the BROTHERHOOD's voice actors.
Even Takayama Minami?
and Miyano Mamoru? <- I'll never get over the fact that Suou Tamaki = Yagami Light.
. I guess I like the manga better but I like the first anime more...I wonder if that makes sense?
. Riza Hawkeye is pretty on FMA too.